a sermon preached by the Rev. Dr. Tim W. Jensen
at the First Religious Society in Carlisle MA
Sunday March 21st, 2004
Opening Words: "Be more concerned with your character than your reputation, because your character is what you really are; your reputation is merely what others think you are." --John Wooden
[extemporaneous thanks to the Skyloom Dancers....]
This is one of my favorite times of the year. It’s the annual return of the “Big Dance” -- the NCAA college basketball tournament, or “March Madness” as it is sometimes called -- an opportunity to watch some of the most exciting basketball played anywhere, by both Men’s and Women’s teams....in an intense, single-elimination format that always seems to produce more than its fair share of dramatic, buzzer-beating finishes, and exhilarating human drama, and unexpected triumphs and defeats....all in the space of three long weekends. For a basketball fan in particular, there’s nothing quite like it...especially for those of us of a theological bent. Last night the DePaul Blue Demons were easily eliminated by the Huskies of U Conn (as in the University of Connecticut, not the Canadian territory), but at least both Duke and Wake Forest will be advancing to next week’s Sweet Sixteen, which means that it’s still theoretically possible for the Blue Devils and the Demon Deacons to meet in the championship game in San Antonio on April 5th: now wouldn’t that be a match-up made in heaven? (Not that I had it that way on MY bracket; I was expecting Stanford to go all the way this year, but they lost last night to Alabama after nearly sending the game into overtime at the buzzer, which was almost as painful as seeing my precious Gonzaga get blown out of Key Arena by a team like Nevada).
But I honestly think that the most emotionally intense game played yesterday was the Wilmington Lady Quakers’ comeback victory over the previously undefeated Bowdin Polar Bears, 59-53, in the Women’s Division III championship game. This was one of those great games where you just wish that both teams could go home winners, and I kinda like to think that maybe in this particular instance, they both did. My daughter was a Division III college athlete, so I know firsthand that there are no scholarships in Division III; these kids truly do play “for the love of the game,” and thus exemplify the advertisements that have been running throughout the tournament, which conclude with the tag: “There are over 360,000 NCAA student athletes, and just about all of us will be going pro in something other than sports.” But they still practice and compete as hard as they can; they still “play their hearts out,” and “leave it all out on the floor.” They still know what it means to be a part of a team, working together over the course of a season to achieve the shared goal of winning a championship.
When we first started thinking about and planning this particular Sunday service several months ago now, the theme was originally going to be “Peace.” But as the time grew closer, and I had a chance to watch the dancers rehearse together, and work out their choreography and adapt it to this space, this other theme of “teamwork” came to mind. Teamwork is a concept I have always associated with competition, first with sports and then by analogy with business, or even war. But teamwork is also obviously about cooperation, and ultimately about performance; and teams not only work, they also play. As a kid growing up, I played on lots of teams. I was told that TEAM was an acronym for “Together Everyone Achieves More” and also that There is no “I” in “Team.” But no one ever bothered to mention the more basic definition of “two or more animals (typically horses or mules, but also often oxen and even dogs) yoked together to the same vehicle or plow,” and driven (naturally) by a “teamster.” Being part of a team certainly empowers its members to accomplish more together than any one of them could alone. But there is also a price to be paid with respect to a loss of individuality and personal freedom (sometimes expressed in the sentiment “unless you are the lead dog, the view never changes”); which is just a colorful way of saying that the same yoke that allows a team to pull together also binds them together in such a way that unless they move together, they are incapable of moving at all.
In this age of the automobile, and the internal combustion engine which makes autonomous mobility possible, teams of draft animals are not really a big part of our daily experience any more. Instead, as I mentioned earlier, we tend to associate teams with both sports and the workplace -- where the emphasis on competition sometimes obscures the more basic sense of cooperation essential to effective teamwork. In this context, members of teams sometimes compete with one another as well as with their “external” opponents -- for promotions and raises, for glory and “playing time.” Sometimes this competition becomes so intense that it destroys the integrity of the team itself, so that no one wins and everybody loses. The real success of a team is measured, not by its momentary victories, but by its ability to continue to work together smoothly over time, while adapting itself effectively to changing circumstances.
This cooperation need not always be so rigid as that of two oxen yoked together. So long as the skills of the teammates compliment and support one another, almost any combination is possible. For example, the most basic kind of a team is a simple partnership -- two individuals working together toward a shared goal. Like a marriage. Have you ever thought about the fact that every marriage is the same, yet no two marriages are alike? Or maybe it’s the other way around.... This paradox has been on my mind a lot lately, especially now that same-sex marriage has jumped to the front burner and boiled over as a potential wedge issue in the upcoming Presidential election. Within the structure of the institution of marriage, each couple has the freedom to work out the nuances of their own unique partnership, to form a team. And this publicly sanctioned privacy is what makes marriage sacred.
There’s a passage from Anne Morrow Lindbergh’s Gift from the Sea that I often like to read at weddings because it expresses this insight so articulately. Lindbergh wrote that “a good relationship has a pattern like a dance, and is built on some of the same rules. The partners do not need to hold on tightly, because they move confidently in the same pattern, intricate, but also gay and swift and free, like a country dance of Mozart’s To touch heavily would be to arrest the pattern and freeze the movement, to check the endlessly changing beauty of its unfolding. There is no place here for the possessive clutch, the clinging arm, the heavy hand; only the barest touch in passing. Now arm in arm, now face to face, now back to back -- it does not matter which, because they know that they are partners moving to the same rhythm, creating a pattern together, and being invisibly nourished by it. The joy of such a pattern is not only the joy of creation or the joy of participation, it is also the joy of living in the moment. Lightness of touch and living in the moment are intertwined....”
As a minister, helping people create this kind of partnership in their marriage is part of my job. But as you may have already figured out, as a human being my real passion is not dancing, but basketball. Five players, one ball, and an equal number of opponents standing between you and your goal...and the most complicated part is that you can’t just walk up and put the ball in the basket, because the basket is ten feet off the ground and walking with the ball is not allowed. And so you have to learn how to play as a team -- how to share the ball and communicate with your teammates in order to outwit your opponents and prevent them from preventing you from doing what you want to do more often than they are able to do it themselves. Sounds complicated, doesn’t it? But it’s really very simple. The only game more simple is soccer, where the goal is still at ground level, and the only real rule is that you can’t use your hands.
But simply because something appears to be simple doesn’t meant that it is easy. Because the challenge is not in the task. The challenge is learning to work as a team, as the tasks themselves grow increasingly more difficult and more complicated. I’ve already covered all the basics, but let’s just go over them one more time so that we can all see how they fit together. Teamwork is about learning to play together. Or about performing together in a cooperative way in order to achieve a shared goal. The key concepts here are “shared,” “cooperative,” and “together,” and the one essential element which makes all these things possible is good communication. Communication allows a group to identify the goals, and to articulate plans for achieving them which every member of the team understands and can agree to. It allows the team to share information about how things are going, and to make adjustments, to offer encouragement, to interact.
In time, good communication also creates something we sometimes call “chemistry” -- a shared knowledge of one’s self and one’s teammates -- your skills, your role, and the skills and roles of everyone else as well, grounded in shared experience and mutual trust, and which allows teammates to anticipate what the others on the team are going to do, sometimes even before they seem to know themselves.
And the catalyst of this chemistry is leadership: the ability to make the people around you better, through teaching and planning, organization, motivation, analysis and correction. Leadership is a complicated topic -- one worthy, no doubt, of at least one sermon all its own. But the great irony of leadership is that leaders typically end up limiting their own individual performance in order to improve the overall performance of the group. A good coach can lead a winning team, yet never score a single point...nor even touch the ball for that matter, except maybe to hand it to the players at the beginning of practice, and pick it up again when practice is over. And at the same time, talented players can sometimes try to “take over” a game to the detriment of a team’s overall performance, essentially taking their teammates out of the game through their own misguided attempts to dominate their opponents single-handedly.
I’ve seen it happen more times than I care to recall. It’s a common fault, and the more talented a player is, the more stubbornly they cling to it. Jr. High School boys are the worst. You get the ball, and the first thing you do is put your head down and dribble as hard as you can with your strong hand toward the basket. It used to work every time in the driveway, but now instead of one-on-one you are going one-on-five, so the next thing you know you find yourself cut-off at the baseline and surrounded by your opponents, at which point you either fire up a wild shot somewhere in the direction of the basket (whether or not you can actually see it), or else finally get it in your head to try to pass the ball to one of your teammates, all of whom are circling around you like vultures, waving their arms and shouting out your name in the hope of getting a chance to do exactly the same thing themselves once they get their hands on the ball. And, of course, the worst thing that can happen at this point is that the ball goes through the basket -- because that will simply encourage you to try it again the next time you touch the ball.
But the point I want to make, metaphorically speaking of course, is that we all start out this way....trying to do it all ourselves, assuming no one else can do it as well as we can, reluctant to trust anyone else, blind to our own shortcomings and harshly critical of the perceived failures of others. But if we are lucky, we will fail often enough early enough to realize that there’s a better way. And we will start to watch the more experienced players, and the more successful teams; we will listen to what they have to teach us, learn from our mistakes, and in time discover what it truly means to be a part of a team ourselves, working together cooperatively in mutual trust and true partnership with others in order to achieve our common goals. And at this point we discover the REAL miracle of teamwork -- that by letting go of our desire to do it all ourselves, we acquire the freedom to do what we do best, in cooperation with others whose talents compliment our own. And thus together, as a team, we each are allowed to become more completely who we are.
READING: from Hoops Nation: a guided to America’s best pickup basketball by Chris Ballard.
Why You Should Always Pick the Old Guy Instead of the Young Guy When Choosing Teams
* More shots for you!
* Almost always a better passer and team player than younger guys.
* Might have a mean pet shot.
* Won’t hinder your triple-double quest by stealing any rebounds.
* You can blame him for any defensive lapses the team encounters.
* He’ll use up his full complement of twenty-five fouls.
* You’ll always have a trailer on the break.
* He could be an influential businessman who will hire you someday.
Tuesday, March 23, 2004
Sunday, March 7, 2004
EQUITY
a sermon preached by the Rev. Dr. Tim W. Jensen
at the First Religious Society in Carlisle, MA
Sunday March 7th, 2004
OPENING WORDS: “Not to give to those in need what to you is superfluous is akin to fraud.” -- St. Augustine
READING: Deuteronomy 15: 7-11 [12-18]
If you type the word “equity” into an internet search engine like Google or Yahoo, the first “hit” you will undoubtedly come across will be the web page for the British trade union for actors and other performing artists of that same name. But if you look over to the side of your screen, at the so-called “sponsored links,” what you will find will be a long list of solicitation after solicitation for home equity loans and credit lines. This is how “equity” is most commonly understood and used in ordinary conversation: the equity in our homes, or perhaps “equities” in which we invested the form of common stock, “shares” of some commercial enterprise which we own “corporately” in the company of other investors. And just as an aside, I learned the other day (from a very credible source), that there is now over a billion dollars worth of real estate equity here in the Town of Carlisle. A billion dollars is a lot of money, by any measure...and of course, because I live in a church-owned parsonage, I don’t actually share in any of it. But that doesn’t mean that I’m not invested in this community, or that I don’t have an interest in what goes on here, sharing in the ups and downs of the fortunes of my neighbors and fellow creatures.
The word “equity” itself comes from the Latin word “æques” meaning “equal” (and which should not be confused with the similar sounding “equus” meaning “horse”). If you look it up in any half-way decent unabridged etymological dictionary, you will basically find some combination of the same small handful of definitions, all of which build in slightly different directions on this original root meaning. In its most basic sense, “equity” means “fairness,” and “equitable” is essentially a synonym for “fair” or “even-handed.” More precisely, equity refers to the legal principle of impartiality, which asserts that every individual has the same right to be fairly heard, and to stand equally with all others before the law -- that we are all entitled to our day in court.
Then comes the financial sense that we’ve been talking about already -- the value of Property (most typically, but not exclusively, Real Estate) minus the amount owed against it...in other words, the part you own “free and fair,” without encumbrance, and which you have a right to redeem in a reasonable time even in the event of foreclosure by a creditor.
Finally, and perhaps most specifically, “Equity” refers to a system of legal rules and doctrines which resorts to general principles of fairness and justice, at times even superseding existing statutes or the common law, whenever established law proves inadequate for just settlement and an equitable resolution of a problem or conflict. In other words, Equity law is basically carte blanc for all those so-called “activist judges,” who are empowered by centuries of British and American legal tradition to root out injustice whenever it comes before them, by relying upon their own best judgment, and a fundamental spirit of fairness and equity .
Now all this leads me to the real question that I want to look at today, which is How do we go about creating “equity” in a Society? -- the kind of community which not only embraces basic principles of fairness and impartiality, but also one in which everyone gets a fairly even-handed opportunity to “buy in” and enjoy an equitable share of its underlying “value.” This is obviously a very complicated topic, and certainly not one which we are going to be able to exhaust in just a few minutes preaching on a Sunday morning. But it’s also a problem that should deeply concern each and every one of us, since it directly affects the quality of both the local and the world community in which we live. Theologians and Social Ethicists in particular sometimes talk about this problem in terms of Economic or “distributive” Justice -- how do we fairly divide up the wealth of a society, so that everyone receives an equitable share?
Not necessarily an equal share, since that would probably be impossible even if it were desirable. But an EQUITABLE share -- a fair share -- whatever that may be. Enough, perhaps, to keep body and soul together. Or maybe enough to assure every individual of life, and liberty, and perhaps even a little happiness...or at least the opportunity to pursue it. Economic justice is about more than merely an equitable distribution of wealth. Ultimately, it’s about relationships -- about benefits and privileges, rights, duties and responsibilities, and how they are shared within a society. Who owes what to whom and why? What kind of obligations do those whom God has smiled upon owe the less-fortunate, and what must the latter do to collect?
Ideas about what is fair and equitable vary from place to place and over time, and even for a single individual over the course of a lifetime. A young child will scream “That’s Not Fair!” whenever they don’t get their way, but as we grow older we come to realize that life isn’t always fair even though we wish it were...and that sometimes we can’t get what we want, or even what we need, no matter how hard we try. Perhaps our ideas about what we “really need” also change over time, as we come to understand our own needs and the needs of others better and more completely. Food, Clothing, Shelter, Education, Health Care, the opportunity to earn an honest living (as contrasted with the opportunity to “make a killing”).
Think about it for a moment: what might you personally add to or subtract from this list? What about transportation, for example: the freedom to move efficiently and affordably from place to place? What about the opportunity to fall in love and form a family...with someone of a different religion? With someone from a different race? With someone the same sex as yourself? As Americans, we tend to be uniquely militant about defending our own perceived “rights” and “freedoms,” but we can sometimes become a little short-sighted when it comes to acknowledging the accompanying duties and responsibilities, or defending the rights of others....especially when they are asserting the right to be different than us.
But the principle of equity insists that all individuals be treated impartially and even-handedly. There should NEVER be two standards of fairness: one for people like us, and another for people different than us. If anything, society should go out of its way to protect those who are incapable of protecting themselves: the widows, the orphans, the strangers. This understanding of equity goes all the way back to the Bible, to the ancient legal codes of Leviticus and Deuteronomy. I’ve always been fascinated by the attempts of certain individuals to read these books “literally,” as a set of divinely-inspired rules and regulations appropriate to governing contemporary behavior. Because more often than not, they aren’t actually interpreting these Scriptures literally at all -- instead, they read them through the filters of their own prejudice, finding support for things they already believe and naively ignoring or misinterpreting what they find disagreeable or don’t understand. And because they read them out of context, they often overlook the more basic, undergirding ethical principles which still give these texts contemporary relevance, despite the fact that they were originally written for a society which no longer exists and which was very different from our own.
Not always, of course. There are still people who “get it” -- some of them very conservative people theologically -- but who understand that just because the Bible talks about slavery (a lot), it doesn’t mean that we have a God-given right to own slaves, or that we should execute adulterers and disobedient children by publicly pelting them to death with heavy stones just because that’s what someone said you ought to do 3000 years ago. In order to truly understand what these texts are all about, you need to read them anthropologically -- you need to understand them accurately in their original context, discern the underlying ethical principles which give them their coherence, and then apply those principles meaningfully to contemporary times. And it’s a very difficult process, because no matter how excellent a scholar one may be, it is impossible not to bring SOME level of contemporary bias to the task. And yet, properly handled, this can be an important tool of discernment in its own right. The things that seem the most strange and unusual are the ones we should be most attentive to. And those that feel the most familiar likewise those which should be approached most skeptically and suspiciously.
There are times (not many, but a few) when I kinda wish that I were a preacher in an honest-to-God Bible-believing church, so that I could have the liberty to go line by line through a passage like the one I read earlier from the Book of Deuteronomy, and really “open the Scripture” to all of you without being afraid of starting a riot. (Of course, if this really were an honest-to-God Bible-Believing church, I would probably cause a riot anyway, just because of the nature of my exegesis). Because even though that particular passage may seem like a relatively straight-forward exhortation to give generously to one’s less-fortunate neighbors, it comes in the midst of a series of similarly prescriptive passages concerning kosher dietary laws, the practice of tithing, the notion of the so-called “sabbatical year,” (a kind of mini-jubilee or “sabbath” every seventh year, at which time creditors forgave the outstanding debts of their neighbors), and finally the equitable treatment of someone who has sold themselves to you as a slave.
And when you examine these passages side by side and in their historical and cultural context, you start to realize that these “laws” are not really about doing nice things for your neighbors out of the goodness of your heart or because it pleases God; they involve instead a systematic redistribution of wealth from the rich to the poor FOR THE GOOD OF THE COMMUNITY ITSELF, a community which includes both rich and poor, all of whom face changing fortunes, all of whom are God’s people. It’s not about charity, or doing good works. It is an investment in what is sometimes called “Social Capital” -- strengthening the relationships which bind us together as neighbors, and allow us to depend on one another in times of crisis.
Of course, here in America in the 21st century, we do things exactly the opposite -- we encumber our children and our children’s children with massive amounts of debt in order to put more money in the pockets of the wealthiest 1% of the population, while at the same time jeopardizing the retirement and health care benefits of an entire generation. And I know there are many who dismiss this kind of talk as partisan political rhetoric, but if you just take a step back from it for a moment and try to look at the situation dispassionately, I think you’ll see that there are fundamental questions of equity and social justice at issue here, and that they concern us all, regardless of our political sentiments.
I believe in the entrepreneurial spirit. I believe in free enterprise, and a market economy -- I believe that incentives are important, and that economic growth, increased productivity, and the creation of wealth are all good things. But I also believe in environmental regulation, in living wages, in health and safety standards, and a society that looks first to protect the lives and livelihoods of its most vulnerable members, rather than subsidizing the extravagant lifestyles of its most affluent. Who really needs meaningful financial incentives more desperately: middle-aged corporate executives like Ken Lay and Dennis Kozlowski, or the 17-year-old inner-city High School drop-out, who is convinced by his entire life experience that there will never be a place at the table for him, simply because of the color of his skin? And even if they all end up in prison, as so many young African American males do these days, do you really think that there’s even the slightest chance that he will find himself eating at the same table as Dennis and Kenny-boy?
A good rant is healthy every now and again; it gets the blood flowing, and inspires the heart to reach out once more into the community, and help to do God’s work in the world. And I just want to say, here at the end of the hour, that I’m very proud of the work that this congregation does in the area of Social Action. Through our on-going partnership with Habitat, through our support of the Open Pantry and the House of Hope, the Bartlett School, the Sharing Foundation, and the various other programs and community agencies we reach out to and are involved with, we help to make small but significant improvements in the lives of hundreds of our “neighbors and fellow creatures” every year; and I know that there are many individuals in this church who do even more in their private lives, and are an inspiration and a good example to us all. Yet as important as this work is, the problems are even bigger. Private Charities and faith-based organizations simply can’t do it all; society as a whole needs to be reminded to make enough room for everyone in the boat, so that we all can float with the rising tide, rather than leaving some of us behind to sink beneath the waves and drown.
at the First Religious Society in Carlisle, MA
Sunday March 7th, 2004
OPENING WORDS: “Not to give to those in need what to you is superfluous is akin to fraud.” -- St. Augustine
READING: Deuteronomy 15: 7-11 [12-18]
If you type the word “equity” into an internet search engine like Google or Yahoo, the first “hit” you will undoubtedly come across will be the web page for the British trade union for actors and other performing artists of that same name. But if you look over to the side of your screen, at the so-called “sponsored links,” what you will find will be a long list of solicitation after solicitation for home equity loans and credit lines. This is how “equity” is most commonly understood and used in ordinary conversation: the equity in our homes, or perhaps “equities” in which we invested the form of common stock, “shares” of some commercial enterprise which we own “corporately” in the company of other investors. And just as an aside, I learned the other day (from a very credible source), that there is now over a billion dollars worth of real estate equity here in the Town of Carlisle. A billion dollars is a lot of money, by any measure...and of course, because I live in a church-owned parsonage, I don’t actually share in any of it. But that doesn’t mean that I’m not invested in this community, or that I don’t have an interest in what goes on here, sharing in the ups and downs of the fortunes of my neighbors and fellow creatures.
The word “equity” itself comes from the Latin word “æques” meaning “equal” (and which should not be confused with the similar sounding “equus” meaning “horse”). If you look it up in any half-way decent unabridged etymological dictionary, you will basically find some combination of the same small handful of definitions, all of which build in slightly different directions on this original root meaning. In its most basic sense, “equity” means “fairness,” and “equitable” is essentially a synonym for “fair” or “even-handed.” More precisely, equity refers to the legal principle of impartiality, which asserts that every individual has the same right to be fairly heard, and to stand equally with all others before the law -- that we are all entitled to our day in court.
Then comes the financial sense that we’ve been talking about already -- the value of Property (most typically, but not exclusively, Real Estate) minus the amount owed against it...in other words, the part you own “free and fair,” without encumbrance, and which you have a right to redeem in a reasonable time even in the event of foreclosure by a creditor.
Finally, and perhaps most specifically, “Equity” refers to a system of legal rules and doctrines which resorts to general principles of fairness and justice, at times even superseding existing statutes or the common law, whenever established law proves inadequate for just settlement and an equitable resolution of a problem or conflict. In other words, Equity law is basically carte blanc for all those so-called “activist judges,” who are empowered by centuries of British and American legal tradition to root out injustice whenever it comes before them, by relying upon their own best judgment, and a fundamental spirit of fairness and equity .
Now all this leads me to the real question that I want to look at today, which is How do we go about creating “equity” in a Society? -- the kind of community which not only embraces basic principles of fairness and impartiality, but also one in which everyone gets a fairly even-handed opportunity to “buy in” and enjoy an equitable share of its underlying “value.” This is obviously a very complicated topic, and certainly not one which we are going to be able to exhaust in just a few minutes preaching on a Sunday morning. But it’s also a problem that should deeply concern each and every one of us, since it directly affects the quality of both the local and the world community in which we live. Theologians and Social Ethicists in particular sometimes talk about this problem in terms of Economic or “distributive” Justice -- how do we fairly divide up the wealth of a society, so that everyone receives an equitable share?
Not necessarily an equal share, since that would probably be impossible even if it were desirable. But an EQUITABLE share -- a fair share -- whatever that may be. Enough, perhaps, to keep body and soul together. Or maybe enough to assure every individual of life, and liberty, and perhaps even a little happiness...or at least the opportunity to pursue it. Economic justice is about more than merely an equitable distribution of wealth. Ultimately, it’s about relationships -- about benefits and privileges, rights, duties and responsibilities, and how they are shared within a society. Who owes what to whom and why? What kind of obligations do those whom God has smiled upon owe the less-fortunate, and what must the latter do to collect?
Ideas about what is fair and equitable vary from place to place and over time, and even for a single individual over the course of a lifetime. A young child will scream “That’s Not Fair!” whenever they don’t get their way, but as we grow older we come to realize that life isn’t always fair even though we wish it were...and that sometimes we can’t get what we want, or even what we need, no matter how hard we try. Perhaps our ideas about what we “really need” also change over time, as we come to understand our own needs and the needs of others better and more completely. Food, Clothing, Shelter, Education, Health Care, the opportunity to earn an honest living (as contrasted with the opportunity to “make a killing”).
Think about it for a moment: what might you personally add to or subtract from this list? What about transportation, for example: the freedom to move efficiently and affordably from place to place? What about the opportunity to fall in love and form a family...with someone of a different religion? With someone from a different race? With someone the same sex as yourself? As Americans, we tend to be uniquely militant about defending our own perceived “rights” and “freedoms,” but we can sometimes become a little short-sighted when it comes to acknowledging the accompanying duties and responsibilities, or defending the rights of others....especially when they are asserting the right to be different than us.
But the principle of equity insists that all individuals be treated impartially and even-handedly. There should NEVER be two standards of fairness: one for people like us, and another for people different than us. If anything, society should go out of its way to protect those who are incapable of protecting themselves: the widows, the orphans, the strangers. This understanding of equity goes all the way back to the Bible, to the ancient legal codes of Leviticus and Deuteronomy. I’ve always been fascinated by the attempts of certain individuals to read these books “literally,” as a set of divinely-inspired rules and regulations appropriate to governing contemporary behavior. Because more often than not, they aren’t actually interpreting these Scriptures literally at all -- instead, they read them through the filters of their own prejudice, finding support for things they already believe and naively ignoring or misinterpreting what they find disagreeable or don’t understand. And because they read them out of context, they often overlook the more basic, undergirding ethical principles which still give these texts contemporary relevance, despite the fact that they were originally written for a society which no longer exists and which was very different from our own.
Not always, of course. There are still people who “get it” -- some of them very conservative people theologically -- but who understand that just because the Bible talks about slavery (a lot), it doesn’t mean that we have a God-given right to own slaves, or that we should execute adulterers and disobedient children by publicly pelting them to death with heavy stones just because that’s what someone said you ought to do 3000 years ago. In order to truly understand what these texts are all about, you need to read them anthropologically -- you need to understand them accurately in their original context, discern the underlying ethical principles which give them their coherence, and then apply those principles meaningfully to contemporary times. And it’s a very difficult process, because no matter how excellent a scholar one may be, it is impossible not to bring SOME level of contemporary bias to the task. And yet, properly handled, this can be an important tool of discernment in its own right. The things that seem the most strange and unusual are the ones we should be most attentive to. And those that feel the most familiar likewise those which should be approached most skeptically and suspiciously.
There are times (not many, but a few) when I kinda wish that I were a preacher in an honest-to-God Bible-believing church, so that I could have the liberty to go line by line through a passage like the one I read earlier from the Book of Deuteronomy, and really “open the Scripture” to all of you without being afraid of starting a riot. (Of course, if this really were an honest-to-God Bible-Believing church, I would probably cause a riot anyway, just because of the nature of my exegesis). Because even though that particular passage may seem like a relatively straight-forward exhortation to give generously to one’s less-fortunate neighbors, it comes in the midst of a series of similarly prescriptive passages concerning kosher dietary laws, the practice of tithing, the notion of the so-called “sabbatical year,” (a kind of mini-jubilee or “sabbath” every seventh year, at which time creditors forgave the outstanding debts of their neighbors), and finally the equitable treatment of someone who has sold themselves to you as a slave.
And when you examine these passages side by side and in their historical and cultural context, you start to realize that these “laws” are not really about doing nice things for your neighbors out of the goodness of your heart or because it pleases God; they involve instead a systematic redistribution of wealth from the rich to the poor FOR THE GOOD OF THE COMMUNITY ITSELF, a community which includes both rich and poor, all of whom face changing fortunes, all of whom are God’s people. It’s not about charity, or doing good works. It is an investment in what is sometimes called “Social Capital” -- strengthening the relationships which bind us together as neighbors, and allow us to depend on one another in times of crisis.
Of course, here in America in the 21st century, we do things exactly the opposite -- we encumber our children and our children’s children with massive amounts of debt in order to put more money in the pockets of the wealthiest 1% of the population, while at the same time jeopardizing the retirement and health care benefits of an entire generation. And I know there are many who dismiss this kind of talk as partisan political rhetoric, but if you just take a step back from it for a moment and try to look at the situation dispassionately, I think you’ll see that there are fundamental questions of equity and social justice at issue here, and that they concern us all, regardless of our political sentiments.
I believe in the entrepreneurial spirit. I believe in free enterprise, and a market economy -- I believe that incentives are important, and that economic growth, increased productivity, and the creation of wealth are all good things. But I also believe in environmental regulation, in living wages, in health and safety standards, and a society that looks first to protect the lives and livelihoods of its most vulnerable members, rather than subsidizing the extravagant lifestyles of its most affluent. Who really needs meaningful financial incentives more desperately: middle-aged corporate executives like Ken Lay and Dennis Kozlowski, or the 17-year-old inner-city High School drop-out, who is convinced by his entire life experience that there will never be a place at the table for him, simply because of the color of his skin? And even if they all end up in prison, as so many young African American males do these days, do you really think that there’s even the slightest chance that he will find himself eating at the same table as Dennis and Kenny-boy?
A good rant is healthy every now and again; it gets the blood flowing, and inspires the heart to reach out once more into the community, and help to do God’s work in the world. And I just want to say, here at the end of the hour, that I’m very proud of the work that this congregation does in the area of Social Action. Through our on-going partnership with Habitat, through our support of the Open Pantry and the House of Hope, the Bartlett School, the Sharing Foundation, and the various other programs and community agencies we reach out to and are involved with, we help to make small but significant improvements in the lives of hundreds of our “neighbors and fellow creatures” every year; and I know that there are many individuals in this church who do even more in their private lives, and are an inspiration and a good example to us all. Yet as important as this work is, the problems are even bigger. Private Charities and faith-based organizations simply can’t do it all; society as a whole needs to be reminded to make enough room for everyone in the boat, so that we all can float with the rising tide, rather than leaving some of us behind to sink beneath the waves and drown.
Sunday, February 29, 2004
TENACITY
a sermon preached by the Rev. Dr. Tim W. Jensen
at the First Religious Society in Carlisle, Massachusetts
Sunday February 29th, 2004
Opening Words:
“Nothing in the world can take the place of persistence. Talent will not; nothing is more common than unsuccessful men with talent. Genius will not; unrewarded genius is almost a proverb. Education will not; the world is full of educated derelicts. Persistence and determination alone are omnipotent. The slogan, 'Press on,' has solved and always will solve the problems of the human race.” --Calvin Coolidge
*****
Five Sundays in a February is a rarity: it only happens once every twenty-eight years, which means that this is the first time it has ever taken place in the time I’ve been a minister. The last time it happened was in 1976 -- I was a nineteen-year-old sophomore at the University of Washington, living in the closest thing to a garrett I could afford -- an ancient dorm room in Hansee Hall that was, literally, smaller than a lot of walk-in closets I’ve seen -- and working day and night on a manuscript that I was certain would win me fame, fortune, and literary immortality: a one-act play with the working title “Faust: the Musical.” And it won’t happen again until 2032, at which point I will be 75 and hopefully retired...although perhaps still available to fill a pulpit now and then for a colleague confronting an extra Sunday, and thus supplement whatever meager Social Security benefits may still be available to those of us who have the good fortune to live so long.
I’ve actually been thinking quite a bit about Time this past week. Like many of you, I imagine, I grew up thinking of time as something that could be neatly divided into three discrete components: Past, Present, and Future -- What Was, What Is, What Yet Shall Be. But as I’ve grown older, I’ve come to see that Time is not nearly so tidy as once I thought. Take the Past, for instance. As a historian I quickly learned that because human memory is imperfect, and even the most meticulous records likewise contain selective inclusions and omissions, our recollection of “What Was” never truly represents “What REALLY Was” -- it’s always some combination of “if memory serves” and “what might have been,” as hindsight and human imagination combine to filter out regrets and uncomfortable details, minimize embarrassment, emphasize the pleasant and admirable, or sometimes cling to feelings of anger and resentment, even exaggerating their importance as they fester, over time, within a bitter heart. We know that the Past has happened, and that it has made us what we are today...that it can’t be changed, that it is gone forever, that it is useless (even dangerous!) to dwell there for too long...and yet, what passes for history is often simply an imaginary re-creation of a time that never was, on which (often times) not even those who were there can agree on all the details.
Likewise, those who complain about “revisionist history” are often really saying “that’s not how I remember it” or “that’s not what I was told.” But the truth of the matter is that all GOOD history is to some degree revisionist, as time and distance give us a better perspective on the past, allowing us to “look again” at the evidence -- to gather together and RE-vision divergent experiences and recollections, and reconcile them based on our superior hindsight and knowledge of “what happened next.” Just as the news is the first draft of history, history is in turn the final draft of the news. And as any writer knows, the difference between a terrible first draft and a superb final draft is revision.
Of course, predicting the Future is even worse. What Yet Shall Be sounds so determined, so fatalistic. The Future embodies our Destiny, which cannot be predicted or controlled. And yet the Future inevitably contains within it both a wide range of possibilities and an element of choice: we can always imagine an entire panoply of possible alternatives (some of which are always more realistic than others, of course), but at most we can only choose to pursue a relative handful, and the choices that we make shape and limit the range of future, Future Possibilities, while at the same time revealing unforeseen new ones. As with the Past, we experience the Future as an amalgam of imagination and decision -- a dynamic combination of dreams and plans by which we hope to make our aspirations real.
Which brings us at last to the Present. Is “here and now” merely something which lingers for a moment and then passes in an instant, or is there more to it than that? And why do we have such a hard time living in the present moment; why do we spend so much of our lives, our mental and emotional energy, reminiscing about what has gone before, or trying to anticipate what will happen next? And this is not to discount either the pleasure or the importance of nostalgic daydreaming about “better days” both behind and before us. But do we even have a word to describe someone who lives their entire life completely focused on the here and now, on “What Is” in the present moment? I sure can’t think of one. If anything, what images I do have are pejorative: a person who never thinks about the past or the future, but who only “lives for the moment,” is generally considered stupid and short-sighted, or at best somehow lacking in vision and perspective. And yet, you would think that “living in the moment” would be a positive thing, since this moment is all we can really count on in life, it’s right here in front of us, and once it is gone it is gone forever, and will never come again.
The word “tenacious” means, literally, to hold tightly, but in common usage it is often simply a euphemistic synonym for “stubborn.” During the waning years of my marriage, this was a frequent topic of discussion in our household: whether it was the tenacity of our mutual love that was holding us together, or our respective individual stubbornness that was driving us apart. I’m not sure whether we ever really arrived at a satisfactory answer to that question, but in the process we did discover that there are at least two different styles of stubborn, which I came to think of as “bull-headed” and “pig-headed.” Bull-headed is relatively straight-forward. When a bull sees red, he puts his head down and charges, and whenever this happens it’s a pretty good idea not to be standing in his way. Pig-headed is a lot more subtle. When a pig smells a truffle, she will go to great effort to root that truffle out, but if for some reason her initial efforts are frustrated, she’ll try another way, and then another, and another, until she finally wins her prize. Both critters are persistent, but pigs are also patient, and this provides a special resilience to their stubbornness. And just so no one is left confused by the pronouns, I was the pig-headed one in my household (which, I’m sorry to say, often make my partner see red).
And then, just to round out the barnyard, there is always your good old-fashioned Missouri Mule, who simply digs in his feet and refuses to budge whenever he encounters something that doesn’t suit him. The mule, of course, is the poster-animal of stubbornness, but tenacity (it seems to me) entails quite a bit more than simply digging in one’s heels. Patience, Persistence, Resilience -- not just a refusal to give in or let go, but also a refusal to give up...a sense of direction and purpose which one retains even in the face of obstacles and adversity. It’s the attitude of a survivor, who stubbornly clings to both life and hope even as those around them lose first one and then the other. It’s the attitude of success, which is persistent enough to build upon its failures...not by stubbornly attempting the same thing again and again, in the vain hope of a different result, but rather by patiently learning from mistakes and moving forward along a new path, never losing sight of the ultimate goal, never losing confidence that it will someday be achieved.
Tenacity is also differentiated from mere stubbornness by its Vision. The stubborn personality often refuses to give in simply for the sake of not giving in, but the tenacious personality always has a goal in mind. It knows when to let go in order to get something back, and it recognizes when its own inflexibility is getting in the way. Stubbornness is about pride; Tenacity is about Purpose. Stubbornness is a contest of wills; but a tenacious competitor can appreciate a tenacious opponent, and both potentially grow stronger through their struggle together. Stubbornness is a character flaw, blind to its own shortcomings, and thus ultimately self-destructive. But Tenacity is a virtue, which builds character by empowering an individual to overcome both personal frustration and personal discouragement, in addition to whatever external obstacles they may face, in order to achieve a worthy goal.
“Nothing in the world can take the place of persistence. Talent will not; nothing is more common than unsuccessful men with talent. Genius will not; unrewarded genius is almost a proverb. Education will not; the world is full of educated derelicts. Persistence and determination alone are omnipotent. The slogan, 'Press on,' has solved and always will solve the problems of the human race.” For someone with a reputation of being a man of few words, Silent Cal sure said a mouthful when he said all that. And the great irony, of course, is that the Coolidge administration is probably best remembered by historians for doing nothing, for having NOT been the terribly corrupt Harding administration which preceded it (quite likely the worst administration in U.S. history, with the possible exception of Ulysses S. Grant’s) or the Hoover administration which followed, and ushered in the Great Depression. While occupying the White House, Coolidge averaged about 11 hours of sleep a day: rising late, retiring early, and napping for up to four hours every afternoon, a habit which inspired H.L. Mencken to write “Nero fiddled while Rome burned, but Coolidge only snores.” Much of the rest of his day he spent sitting in a rocking chair on the White House porch, smoking cigars and trying not to encourage those who came to speak with him to overstay their welcome by showing any sign of interest in what they had to say. When Groucho Marx spotted Coolidge one evening in the audience at a performance of the Marx Brother’s vaudeville show “Animal Crackers,” he reportedly cried out “Isn’t it past your bedtime, Calvin?” And when Dorothy Parker heard the news of his death, in 1933, she is said to have remarked “How can they tell?” For his own part, Coolidge is known to have quipped that all this shut-eye was in the national interest, since while he was sleeping it was impossible for him to initiate anything new. In Coolidge’s view, “the chief business of the American people IS business,” and the business of government was to stay out of their way.
Equally ironic is the fact that it was Coolidge’s energetic successor, an orphaned, self-made millionaire technocrat whom Coolidge sometimes refered to as “the Wundah Boy,” who ended up lending his name to the shantytowns that sprang up in the aftermath of the 1929 stock market crash, and the 25% unemployment which followed that, and whose reputation has been tenaciously linked with the Great Depression ever since. Herbert Hoover tried everything he could think of to turn the economy around; unfortunately, his mind ran more to optimistic platitudes and a stubborn ideological preference for encouraging private, local inititives than it did effective federal intervention and direct public relief. Herbert Hoover believed that the Great Depression was the result of global economic forces beyond his effective control, and that like a hurricane or some other Act of God, individuals needed to rely upon their own resourcefulness to weather the storm until it passed. “Every time we find solutions outside of government,” he told an audience of struggling farmers, “we have not only strengthened character, but we have preserved our sense of real self-government.” But when voters went to the polls in 1932, they turned him out in a landslide, and supported instead a candidate who insisted that “the country needs and, unless I mistake its temper, the country demands bold, persistent experimentation. It is common sense to take a method and try it. If it fails, admit it frankly and try another. But above all, try something.”
Patience. Persistence. Resilience. Vision. More than talent, more than genius, more even than education, these are the qualities which empower individuals to “press on” in a determined way, and thus eventually overcome whatever obstacles stand between them and their desired goal. And these same qualities can also be found in tenacious institutions, or a tenatious society, where individuals come together to work towards shared and common goals. In his “Maritime History of Massachusetts,” Samuel Eliot Morison described New Englanders as “a tough but nervous, tenacious but restless race...materially ambitious, yet prone to introspection, and subject to waves of religious emotion...a race whose typical member is eternally torn between a passion for righteousness and a desire to get on in the world.” And this same “restless tenacity” is what animates our aspirations as well as our ambitions -- that introspective, at times passionately emotional, religious desire for righteousness which we “hold tightly” in our hands and in our hearts, and which ultimately gives our lives a larger meaning....
at the First Religious Society in Carlisle, Massachusetts
Sunday February 29th, 2004
Opening Words:
“Nothing in the world can take the place of persistence. Talent will not; nothing is more common than unsuccessful men with talent. Genius will not; unrewarded genius is almost a proverb. Education will not; the world is full of educated derelicts. Persistence and determination alone are omnipotent. The slogan, 'Press on,' has solved and always will solve the problems of the human race.” --Calvin Coolidge
*****
Five Sundays in a February is a rarity: it only happens once every twenty-eight years, which means that this is the first time it has ever taken place in the time I’ve been a minister. The last time it happened was in 1976 -- I was a nineteen-year-old sophomore at the University of Washington, living in the closest thing to a garrett I could afford -- an ancient dorm room in Hansee Hall that was, literally, smaller than a lot of walk-in closets I’ve seen -- and working day and night on a manuscript that I was certain would win me fame, fortune, and literary immortality: a one-act play with the working title “Faust: the Musical.” And it won’t happen again until 2032, at which point I will be 75 and hopefully retired...although perhaps still available to fill a pulpit now and then for a colleague confronting an extra Sunday, and thus supplement whatever meager Social Security benefits may still be available to those of us who have the good fortune to live so long.
I’ve actually been thinking quite a bit about Time this past week. Like many of you, I imagine, I grew up thinking of time as something that could be neatly divided into three discrete components: Past, Present, and Future -- What Was, What Is, What Yet Shall Be. But as I’ve grown older, I’ve come to see that Time is not nearly so tidy as once I thought. Take the Past, for instance. As a historian I quickly learned that because human memory is imperfect, and even the most meticulous records likewise contain selective inclusions and omissions, our recollection of “What Was” never truly represents “What REALLY Was” -- it’s always some combination of “if memory serves” and “what might have been,” as hindsight and human imagination combine to filter out regrets and uncomfortable details, minimize embarrassment, emphasize the pleasant and admirable, or sometimes cling to feelings of anger and resentment, even exaggerating their importance as they fester, over time, within a bitter heart. We know that the Past has happened, and that it has made us what we are today...that it can’t be changed, that it is gone forever, that it is useless (even dangerous!) to dwell there for too long...and yet, what passes for history is often simply an imaginary re-creation of a time that never was, on which (often times) not even those who were there can agree on all the details.
Likewise, those who complain about “revisionist history” are often really saying “that’s not how I remember it” or “that’s not what I was told.” But the truth of the matter is that all GOOD history is to some degree revisionist, as time and distance give us a better perspective on the past, allowing us to “look again” at the evidence -- to gather together and RE-vision divergent experiences and recollections, and reconcile them based on our superior hindsight and knowledge of “what happened next.” Just as the news is the first draft of history, history is in turn the final draft of the news. And as any writer knows, the difference between a terrible first draft and a superb final draft is revision.
Of course, predicting the Future is even worse. What Yet Shall Be sounds so determined, so fatalistic. The Future embodies our Destiny, which cannot be predicted or controlled. And yet the Future inevitably contains within it both a wide range of possibilities and an element of choice: we can always imagine an entire panoply of possible alternatives (some of which are always more realistic than others, of course), but at most we can only choose to pursue a relative handful, and the choices that we make shape and limit the range of future, Future Possibilities, while at the same time revealing unforeseen new ones. As with the Past, we experience the Future as an amalgam of imagination and decision -- a dynamic combination of dreams and plans by which we hope to make our aspirations real.
Which brings us at last to the Present. Is “here and now” merely something which lingers for a moment and then passes in an instant, or is there more to it than that? And why do we have such a hard time living in the present moment; why do we spend so much of our lives, our mental and emotional energy, reminiscing about what has gone before, or trying to anticipate what will happen next? And this is not to discount either the pleasure or the importance of nostalgic daydreaming about “better days” both behind and before us. But do we even have a word to describe someone who lives their entire life completely focused on the here and now, on “What Is” in the present moment? I sure can’t think of one. If anything, what images I do have are pejorative: a person who never thinks about the past or the future, but who only “lives for the moment,” is generally considered stupid and short-sighted, or at best somehow lacking in vision and perspective. And yet, you would think that “living in the moment” would be a positive thing, since this moment is all we can really count on in life, it’s right here in front of us, and once it is gone it is gone forever, and will never come again.
The word “tenacious” means, literally, to hold tightly, but in common usage it is often simply a euphemistic synonym for “stubborn.” During the waning years of my marriage, this was a frequent topic of discussion in our household: whether it was the tenacity of our mutual love that was holding us together, or our respective individual stubbornness that was driving us apart. I’m not sure whether we ever really arrived at a satisfactory answer to that question, but in the process we did discover that there are at least two different styles of stubborn, which I came to think of as “bull-headed” and “pig-headed.” Bull-headed is relatively straight-forward. When a bull sees red, he puts his head down and charges, and whenever this happens it’s a pretty good idea not to be standing in his way. Pig-headed is a lot more subtle. When a pig smells a truffle, she will go to great effort to root that truffle out, but if for some reason her initial efforts are frustrated, she’ll try another way, and then another, and another, until she finally wins her prize. Both critters are persistent, but pigs are also patient, and this provides a special resilience to their stubbornness. And just so no one is left confused by the pronouns, I was the pig-headed one in my household (which, I’m sorry to say, often make my partner see red).
And then, just to round out the barnyard, there is always your good old-fashioned Missouri Mule, who simply digs in his feet and refuses to budge whenever he encounters something that doesn’t suit him. The mule, of course, is the poster-animal of stubbornness, but tenacity (it seems to me) entails quite a bit more than simply digging in one’s heels. Patience, Persistence, Resilience -- not just a refusal to give in or let go, but also a refusal to give up...a sense of direction and purpose which one retains even in the face of obstacles and adversity. It’s the attitude of a survivor, who stubbornly clings to both life and hope even as those around them lose first one and then the other. It’s the attitude of success, which is persistent enough to build upon its failures...not by stubbornly attempting the same thing again and again, in the vain hope of a different result, but rather by patiently learning from mistakes and moving forward along a new path, never losing sight of the ultimate goal, never losing confidence that it will someday be achieved.
Tenacity is also differentiated from mere stubbornness by its Vision. The stubborn personality often refuses to give in simply for the sake of not giving in, but the tenacious personality always has a goal in mind. It knows when to let go in order to get something back, and it recognizes when its own inflexibility is getting in the way. Stubbornness is about pride; Tenacity is about Purpose. Stubbornness is a contest of wills; but a tenacious competitor can appreciate a tenacious opponent, and both potentially grow stronger through their struggle together. Stubbornness is a character flaw, blind to its own shortcomings, and thus ultimately self-destructive. But Tenacity is a virtue, which builds character by empowering an individual to overcome both personal frustration and personal discouragement, in addition to whatever external obstacles they may face, in order to achieve a worthy goal.
“Nothing in the world can take the place of persistence. Talent will not; nothing is more common than unsuccessful men with talent. Genius will not; unrewarded genius is almost a proverb. Education will not; the world is full of educated derelicts. Persistence and determination alone are omnipotent. The slogan, 'Press on,' has solved and always will solve the problems of the human race.” For someone with a reputation of being a man of few words, Silent Cal sure said a mouthful when he said all that. And the great irony, of course, is that the Coolidge administration is probably best remembered by historians for doing nothing, for having NOT been the terribly corrupt Harding administration which preceded it (quite likely the worst administration in U.S. history, with the possible exception of Ulysses S. Grant’s) or the Hoover administration which followed, and ushered in the Great Depression. While occupying the White House, Coolidge averaged about 11 hours of sleep a day: rising late, retiring early, and napping for up to four hours every afternoon, a habit which inspired H.L. Mencken to write “Nero fiddled while Rome burned, but Coolidge only snores.” Much of the rest of his day he spent sitting in a rocking chair on the White House porch, smoking cigars and trying not to encourage those who came to speak with him to overstay their welcome by showing any sign of interest in what they had to say. When Groucho Marx spotted Coolidge one evening in the audience at a performance of the Marx Brother’s vaudeville show “Animal Crackers,” he reportedly cried out “Isn’t it past your bedtime, Calvin?” And when Dorothy Parker heard the news of his death, in 1933, she is said to have remarked “How can they tell?” For his own part, Coolidge is known to have quipped that all this shut-eye was in the national interest, since while he was sleeping it was impossible for him to initiate anything new. In Coolidge’s view, “the chief business of the American people IS business,” and the business of government was to stay out of their way.
Equally ironic is the fact that it was Coolidge’s energetic successor, an orphaned, self-made millionaire technocrat whom Coolidge sometimes refered to as “the Wundah Boy,” who ended up lending his name to the shantytowns that sprang up in the aftermath of the 1929 stock market crash, and the 25% unemployment which followed that, and whose reputation has been tenaciously linked with the Great Depression ever since. Herbert Hoover tried everything he could think of to turn the economy around; unfortunately, his mind ran more to optimistic platitudes and a stubborn ideological preference for encouraging private, local inititives than it did effective federal intervention and direct public relief. Herbert Hoover believed that the Great Depression was the result of global economic forces beyond his effective control, and that like a hurricane or some other Act of God, individuals needed to rely upon their own resourcefulness to weather the storm until it passed. “Every time we find solutions outside of government,” he told an audience of struggling farmers, “we have not only strengthened character, but we have preserved our sense of real self-government.” But when voters went to the polls in 1932, they turned him out in a landslide, and supported instead a candidate who insisted that “the country needs and, unless I mistake its temper, the country demands bold, persistent experimentation. It is common sense to take a method and try it. If it fails, admit it frankly and try another. But above all, try something.”
Patience. Persistence. Resilience. Vision. More than talent, more than genius, more even than education, these are the qualities which empower individuals to “press on” in a determined way, and thus eventually overcome whatever obstacles stand between them and their desired goal. And these same qualities can also be found in tenacious institutions, or a tenatious society, where individuals come together to work towards shared and common goals. In his “Maritime History of Massachusetts,” Samuel Eliot Morison described New Englanders as “a tough but nervous, tenacious but restless race...materially ambitious, yet prone to introspection, and subject to waves of religious emotion...a race whose typical member is eternally torn between a passion for righteousness and a desire to get on in the world.” And this same “restless tenacity” is what animates our aspirations as well as our ambitions -- that introspective, at times passionately emotional, religious desire for righteousness which we “hold tightly” in our hands and in our hearts, and which ultimately gives our lives a larger meaning....
Sunday, February 22, 2004
ABUNDANCE!
a sermon preached by the Rev. Dr. Tim W. Jensen
at the First Religious Society in Carlisle, Massachusetts
Sunday February 22th, 2004
OPENING WORDS: “Real happiness is cheap enough, yet how dearly we pay for its counterfeit.” -- Hosea Ballou
I’ve decided that I could get used to this concept of the one-word sermon title. It’s so succinct, so efficient -- and yet so richly evocative as well. Joy! Love! And now Abundance! -- a word which means, literally, “overflowing,” thus making it a perfect compliment to these other topics of recent weeks. Abundant Love. Abundant Joy. Abundant blessings of all sorts: the word simply overflows with connotations of wealth and prosperity, freedom, success and happiness. It’s a word which positively inspires generosity and creativity; and then there’s always that lovely scriptural reference to John 10:10 -- “The thief comes only to steal and kill and destroy; I come that they may have life, and have life more abundantly.” Not “Eternal Life” in the sense of a life-span which lasts forever. But “Abundant Life” -- a life-force which overflows with the Spirit of the Divine, a life-style which is emersed in a consciousness of ultimate meaning and value.
The opposite of abundance might be thought of as scarcity, or deficiency, in which the blessings of life are reduced to a trickle. Poverty and Privation. Hunger, Uncertainty, Fear. I suppose it’s possible to have all these things in abundance as well -- our lives can overflow with the bad as well as with the good, although there is certainly abundant irony in that. And yet, often abundance is in the eye of the beholder...what appears abundant to one may seem barely sufficient, or even inadequate, to another, and how do we determine whose perceptions are correct? In his second Inaugural address in 1937, as America struggled to escape the privations of the Great Depression through a series of controversial federal policies known as the “New Deal,” FDR remarked that “the test of our progress is not whether we add more to the abundance of those who have much; it is whether we provide enough for those who have too little.” Sixty-seven years (and eleven Presidential administrations) later, we seem to have forgotten this fundamental criterion of the worthiness of a society. Has our nation changed so much in just two generations, that we have metaphorically gained the whole world, and lost our own souls? Have we somehow allowed our relative material abundance to distract us from more essential spiritual values of generosity and compassion?
You know, I’ve often had to wonder how it is that such an unrepentant, dyed-in-the-wool Socialist like myself has found himself serving, and serving quite happily and successfully, in such affluent communities as Midland Texas, and Nantucket Island, and now here in Carlisle. I think part of it has to do with the fact that, although I’ve never really had much money myself, I grew up in a fairly affluent household, in a fairly affluent neighborhood, and thus saw close up (and at a very impressionable age) what that was like, along with the abundant psychological pressures that often emerge from wrestling with the temptation of confusing one’s self-worth with one’s net worth. And I think part of it has to do with the fact that I try never to take myself too seriously, which gives others permission not to take me too seriously either, but rather just seriously enough that perhaps they receive some fresh insight into their own lives from looking at life itself from a slightly different perspective.
We Americans like to think that we live in a class-less society. We don’t, really, but since our forebearers once fought a revolution based on the self-evident truths that all white, male property-owners of a certain age were created equal, and endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights, it still gives us comfort to pretend that we do. And one of the consequences of this is that no matter how much (or really, how little) money we may have, we still typically feel like we’re “Middle-Class.” Even Bill Gates (who is certainly smart enough to know better), still basically feels like a very, very, very, very well-to-do Middle Class American. But for the rest of us, this same cultural phenomenon often means that we tend to assume that how we live is “normal,” -- while at the same time privately feeling that anyone who has considerably more than we do is somehow “extravagant,” and wondering how anyone else can get by on anything less. These assumptions don’t generally rise to the level of conscious thought; if we stopped to think about it we would know, intellectually at least, that they weren’t exactly true. But typically we don’t think about it, unless something dramatically changes -- unless we lose our job, or are in danger of losing our job; or (which is sometimes even worse) we receive a sudden financial windfall, like winning the lottery. Our comfortable notions of “appropriate abundance” become disrupted, and we are compelled to recalculate our entire relationship to the material world.
Tied in with all of this is something we sometimes like to call the “Protestant Work Ethic.” This term is derived from the writings of a German Sociologist of Religion named Max Weber, who lived and worked about a hundred years ago. Weber was trying to understand why Western Civilization was the way it was, and he basically ended up blaming it all on Puritan angst. Medieval economists (who were basically monks) understood that Personal Industry combined with Frugality (two good “religious” virtues) would eventually create wealth. But they also understood that Wealth often led to laziness and self-indulgence, which in turn often led to dissolute Poverty...and so they encouraged those who would listen to avoid this problem by continuing to work hard and spend little, and contributing their excess wealth to the less fortunate in the form Christian Charity, which would help you get to heaven. But John Calvin believed that the ultimate fate of any particular individual’s immortal soul had all been determined by God before the beginning of time; it was all predestined, and so (according to Weber) this resulted in a situation where Protestant Christians transformed the spiritual “other-worldly asceticism” of the monastery into the “Worldly Asceticism” embodied in the Spirit of Capitalism, in which industry and frugality continued to remain virtues, but accumulated wealth was reinvested in expanding the enterprise, since Charity was now irrelevant to one’s salvation, while success was considered a tangible sign of God’s pre-determined favor. The wealthier you became, the more it meant God loved you. Or at least that’s how Max Weber saw it.
There are plenty of problems with Weber’s sociology, but the great irony is that because his ideas were so innovative and popular at the time they were first published, in many ways they have become self-fulfilling. In large part this was due to the fact that they provided a theological justification for yet another philosophy, known as Social Darwinism, which was already popular at the time Weber was writing. As you might guess, the Social Darwinists believed that human civilization was essentially a struggle for “survival of the fittest” -- society is divided into “winners” and “losers,” both the rich and the poor get what they deserve, and any attempt to ameliorate the suffering of the latter only makes civilization itself less strong. Social Darwinism is a self-serving philosophy which worships both power and privilege, while essentially renouncing the fundamental principles of compassionate ethical conduct commonly shared among all of the world’s great religions. Yet because it sounds “scientific,” and because of Weber’s observation that within some sects of Protestant Christianity wealth was historically considered a sign of God’s favor, it has proved surprisingly resilient, especially among those who have accumulated some degree of wealth, and who want to believe that they are among God’s favorites.
And even those of use who explicitly reject these values and assumptions sometimes still have to deal with their implicit consequences. In my experience, this problem shows up most directly when we enter into the process of trying to figure out for ourselves the precise relationship between work and lifestyle that we believe will produce for us the greatest level of personal fulfillment. It’s a task we typically first confront when we are young and making decisions about our careers, but in many ways it remains a challenge all our lives, as we continue to grow and learn about what truly makes us feel happy and fulfilled. I personally believe, for example, that frugality is still a very satisfying lifestyle choice. I understand that contemporary American society is mostly based on “consumption,” and the notion that somehow acquiring more stuff will provide us with happiness...and at times I still even buy into that...although I try not to take it too seriously. But you can all probably tell just by the way I dress all week long: “Use it up, wear it out, make it do or do without.” -- I have a whole closet full of stuff like that.
My main problem comes on the other end: trying to figure out where the line is between frugality and parsimony. I don’t mind living cheaply, and I certainly want to feel like I’m getting my money’s worth, but I sure don’t want to be thought of as a cheapskate, either in the way that I treat myself or in my interactions with others. And this brings me to the second part of the equation, which is the realization that generosity is not only an act of charity, of “Love” -- it is also an act of Creativity...a way in which we put our life-energy to work in the world in order to change it for the better. When we allow our Creativity to overflow...when we live life abundantly, sharing our industry with others, good things happen. And this, more than any other thing that we can do, is what gives live meaning.
I want to leave you with just three more brief observations which you can take home with you and ponder over the next few days or weeks, and then maybe when you get a chance you can tell me what you think. And the first of these is the insight that you can almost always get by on a lot less than you think, and that it’s a lot better to figure this out BEFORE you actually have to do it. I have a colleague out on the West Coast who is encouraging folks, as a Lenten discipline, to try to live for six weeks on the minimum wage for their area. I mean, think about that for a moment. Even if we took the mortgage off the table, and ignored things like our pensions and our health insurance, how many of us could actually “get by” on $6.75 an hour, or $270 a week...before taxes? And yet there are lots of people in this country who are trying to get by on this, or even less....and the realization that if you had to you could too is actually rather liberating....which is not at all to minimize the hardship of those who are trying to do it for real. Thoreau said it as well as anyone: “if you are restricted in your range by poverty...you are but confined to the most significant and vital experiences.... It is life near the bone where it is sweetest. You are defended from being a trifler.”
This brings me to the second observation, which is that the Best things in Life truly are free. “Superfluous wealth can buy superfluities only,” Thoreau wrote. “Money is not required to buy one necessary of the soul....” And this is not to suggest that because the best things are free, we don’t need money at all. But remember never to let the scramble for money distract you from enjoying the things that money just can’t buy. Because if you do, you are getting ripped off. You are cheating yourself of the World’s most abundant treasures, the things which ultimately make life worth living.
And finally, don’t forget the principle of Noblesse Oblige -- “to those to whom much is given, much is expected.” This simple idea is what truly ties together all of the activities of a meaningful and fulfilling life. When life has treated you to abundant blessings, pass them on. And if life isn’t treating you so well at the moment, don’t be too proud or stubborn to accept and enjoy the shared abundance of others. Because when we let it be what it truly is, Abundance Overflows. It can’t be contained, it can’t be hoarded, it can’t be bottled and sold in stores, or even saved for a rainy day. But the good news is, there’s more where that came from. And that knowledge is what gives us life, and gives us life more abundantly.
READING: from Walden by Henry David Thoreau
“Do not trouble yourself much to get new things, whether clothes or friends. Turn the old; return to them. Things do not change; we change. Sell your clothes and keep your thoughts. God will see that you do not want society....We are often reminded that if there were bestowed on us the wealth of Croesus, our aims must still be the same, and our means essentially the same. Moreover, if you are restricted in your range by poverty, if you cannot buy books and newspapers, for instance, you are but confined to the most significant and vital experiences; you are compelled to deal with the material which yields the most sugar and the most starch. It is life near the bone where it is sweetest. You are defended from being a trifler. No [one] loses ever on a lower level by magnanimity on a higher. Superfluous wealth can buy superfluities only. Money is not required to buy one necessary of the soul....
“Rather than love, than money, than fame, give me truth....”
a sermon preached by the Rev. Dr. Tim W. Jensen
at the First Religious Society in Carlisle, Massachusetts
Sunday February 22th, 2004
OPENING WORDS: “Real happiness is cheap enough, yet how dearly we pay for its counterfeit.” -- Hosea Ballou
I’ve decided that I could get used to this concept of the one-word sermon title. It’s so succinct, so efficient -- and yet so richly evocative as well. Joy! Love! And now Abundance! -- a word which means, literally, “overflowing,” thus making it a perfect compliment to these other topics of recent weeks. Abundant Love. Abundant Joy. Abundant blessings of all sorts: the word simply overflows with connotations of wealth and prosperity, freedom, success and happiness. It’s a word which positively inspires generosity and creativity; and then there’s always that lovely scriptural reference to John 10:10 -- “The thief comes only to steal and kill and destroy; I come that they may have life, and have life more abundantly.” Not “Eternal Life” in the sense of a life-span which lasts forever. But “Abundant Life” -- a life-force which overflows with the Spirit of the Divine, a life-style which is emersed in a consciousness of ultimate meaning and value.
The opposite of abundance might be thought of as scarcity, or deficiency, in which the blessings of life are reduced to a trickle. Poverty and Privation. Hunger, Uncertainty, Fear. I suppose it’s possible to have all these things in abundance as well -- our lives can overflow with the bad as well as with the good, although there is certainly abundant irony in that. And yet, often abundance is in the eye of the beholder...what appears abundant to one may seem barely sufficient, or even inadequate, to another, and how do we determine whose perceptions are correct? In his second Inaugural address in 1937, as America struggled to escape the privations of the Great Depression through a series of controversial federal policies known as the “New Deal,” FDR remarked that “the test of our progress is not whether we add more to the abundance of those who have much; it is whether we provide enough for those who have too little.” Sixty-seven years (and eleven Presidential administrations) later, we seem to have forgotten this fundamental criterion of the worthiness of a society. Has our nation changed so much in just two generations, that we have metaphorically gained the whole world, and lost our own souls? Have we somehow allowed our relative material abundance to distract us from more essential spiritual values of generosity and compassion?
You know, I’ve often had to wonder how it is that such an unrepentant, dyed-in-the-wool Socialist like myself has found himself serving, and serving quite happily and successfully, in such affluent communities as Midland Texas, and Nantucket Island, and now here in Carlisle. I think part of it has to do with the fact that, although I’ve never really had much money myself, I grew up in a fairly affluent household, in a fairly affluent neighborhood, and thus saw close up (and at a very impressionable age) what that was like, along with the abundant psychological pressures that often emerge from wrestling with the temptation of confusing one’s self-worth with one’s net worth. And I think part of it has to do with the fact that I try never to take myself too seriously, which gives others permission not to take me too seriously either, but rather just seriously enough that perhaps they receive some fresh insight into their own lives from looking at life itself from a slightly different perspective.
We Americans like to think that we live in a class-less society. We don’t, really, but since our forebearers once fought a revolution based on the self-evident truths that all white, male property-owners of a certain age were created equal, and endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights, it still gives us comfort to pretend that we do. And one of the consequences of this is that no matter how much (or really, how little) money we may have, we still typically feel like we’re “Middle-Class.” Even Bill Gates (who is certainly smart enough to know better), still basically feels like a very, very, very, very well-to-do Middle Class American. But for the rest of us, this same cultural phenomenon often means that we tend to assume that how we live is “normal,” -- while at the same time privately feeling that anyone who has considerably more than we do is somehow “extravagant,” and wondering how anyone else can get by on anything less. These assumptions don’t generally rise to the level of conscious thought; if we stopped to think about it we would know, intellectually at least, that they weren’t exactly true. But typically we don’t think about it, unless something dramatically changes -- unless we lose our job, or are in danger of losing our job; or (which is sometimes even worse) we receive a sudden financial windfall, like winning the lottery. Our comfortable notions of “appropriate abundance” become disrupted, and we are compelled to recalculate our entire relationship to the material world.
Tied in with all of this is something we sometimes like to call the “Protestant Work Ethic.” This term is derived from the writings of a German Sociologist of Religion named Max Weber, who lived and worked about a hundred years ago. Weber was trying to understand why Western Civilization was the way it was, and he basically ended up blaming it all on Puritan angst. Medieval economists (who were basically monks) understood that Personal Industry combined with Frugality (two good “religious” virtues) would eventually create wealth. But they also understood that Wealth often led to laziness and self-indulgence, which in turn often led to dissolute Poverty...and so they encouraged those who would listen to avoid this problem by continuing to work hard and spend little, and contributing their excess wealth to the less fortunate in the form Christian Charity, which would help you get to heaven. But John Calvin believed that the ultimate fate of any particular individual’s immortal soul had all been determined by God before the beginning of time; it was all predestined, and so (according to Weber) this resulted in a situation where Protestant Christians transformed the spiritual “other-worldly asceticism” of the monastery into the “Worldly Asceticism” embodied in the Spirit of Capitalism, in which industry and frugality continued to remain virtues, but accumulated wealth was reinvested in expanding the enterprise, since Charity was now irrelevant to one’s salvation, while success was considered a tangible sign of God’s pre-determined favor. The wealthier you became, the more it meant God loved you. Or at least that’s how Max Weber saw it.
There are plenty of problems with Weber’s sociology, but the great irony is that because his ideas were so innovative and popular at the time they were first published, in many ways they have become self-fulfilling. In large part this was due to the fact that they provided a theological justification for yet another philosophy, known as Social Darwinism, which was already popular at the time Weber was writing. As you might guess, the Social Darwinists believed that human civilization was essentially a struggle for “survival of the fittest” -- society is divided into “winners” and “losers,” both the rich and the poor get what they deserve, and any attempt to ameliorate the suffering of the latter only makes civilization itself less strong. Social Darwinism is a self-serving philosophy which worships both power and privilege, while essentially renouncing the fundamental principles of compassionate ethical conduct commonly shared among all of the world’s great religions. Yet because it sounds “scientific,” and because of Weber’s observation that within some sects of Protestant Christianity wealth was historically considered a sign of God’s favor, it has proved surprisingly resilient, especially among those who have accumulated some degree of wealth, and who want to believe that they are among God’s favorites.
And even those of use who explicitly reject these values and assumptions sometimes still have to deal with their implicit consequences. In my experience, this problem shows up most directly when we enter into the process of trying to figure out for ourselves the precise relationship between work and lifestyle that we believe will produce for us the greatest level of personal fulfillment. It’s a task we typically first confront when we are young and making decisions about our careers, but in many ways it remains a challenge all our lives, as we continue to grow and learn about what truly makes us feel happy and fulfilled. I personally believe, for example, that frugality is still a very satisfying lifestyle choice. I understand that contemporary American society is mostly based on “consumption,” and the notion that somehow acquiring more stuff will provide us with happiness...and at times I still even buy into that...although I try not to take it too seriously. But you can all probably tell just by the way I dress all week long: “Use it up, wear it out, make it do or do without.” -- I have a whole closet full of stuff like that.
My main problem comes on the other end: trying to figure out where the line is between frugality and parsimony. I don’t mind living cheaply, and I certainly want to feel like I’m getting my money’s worth, but I sure don’t want to be thought of as a cheapskate, either in the way that I treat myself or in my interactions with others. And this brings me to the second part of the equation, which is the realization that generosity is not only an act of charity, of “Love” -- it is also an act of Creativity...a way in which we put our life-energy to work in the world in order to change it for the better. When we allow our Creativity to overflow...when we live life abundantly, sharing our industry with others, good things happen. And this, more than any other thing that we can do, is what gives live meaning.
I want to leave you with just three more brief observations which you can take home with you and ponder over the next few days or weeks, and then maybe when you get a chance you can tell me what you think. And the first of these is the insight that you can almost always get by on a lot less than you think, and that it’s a lot better to figure this out BEFORE you actually have to do it. I have a colleague out on the West Coast who is encouraging folks, as a Lenten discipline, to try to live for six weeks on the minimum wage for their area. I mean, think about that for a moment. Even if we took the mortgage off the table, and ignored things like our pensions and our health insurance, how many of us could actually “get by” on $6.75 an hour, or $270 a week...before taxes? And yet there are lots of people in this country who are trying to get by on this, or even less....and the realization that if you had to you could too is actually rather liberating....which is not at all to minimize the hardship of those who are trying to do it for real. Thoreau said it as well as anyone: “if you are restricted in your range by poverty...you are but confined to the most significant and vital experiences.... It is life near the bone where it is sweetest. You are defended from being a trifler.”
This brings me to the second observation, which is that the Best things in Life truly are free. “Superfluous wealth can buy superfluities only,” Thoreau wrote. “Money is not required to buy one necessary of the soul....” And this is not to suggest that because the best things are free, we don’t need money at all. But remember never to let the scramble for money distract you from enjoying the things that money just can’t buy. Because if you do, you are getting ripped off. You are cheating yourself of the World’s most abundant treasures, the things which ultimately make life worth living.
And finally, don’t forget the principle of Noblesse Oblige -- “to those to whom much is given, much is expected.” This simple idea is what truly ties together all of the activities of a meaningful and fulfilling life. When life has treated you to abundant blessings, pass them on. And if life isn’t treating you so well at the moment, don’t be too proud or stubborn to accept and enjoy the shared abundance of others. Because when we let it be what it truly is, Abundance Overflows. It can’t be contained, it can’t be hoarded, it can’t be bottled and sold in stores, or even saved for a rainy day. But the good news is, there’s more where that came from. And that knowledge is what gives us life, and gives us life more abundantly.
READING: from Walden by Henry David Thoreau
“Do not trouble yourself much to get new things, whether clothes or friends. Turn the old; return to them. Things do not change; we change. Sell your clothes and keep your thoughts. God will see that you do not want society....We are often reminded that if there were bestowed on us the wealth of Croesus, our aims must still be the same, and our means essentially the same. Moreover, if you are restricted in your range by poverty, if you cannot buy books and newspapers, for instance, you are but confined to the most significant and vital experiences; you are compelled to deal with the material which yields the most sugar and the most starch. It is life near the bone where it is sweetest. You are defended from being a trifler. No [one] loses ever on a lower level by magnanimity on a higher. Superfluous wealth can buy superfluities only. Money is not required to buy one necessary of the soul....
“Rather than love, than money, than fame, give me truth....”
Sunday, February 15, 2004
LOVE!
a sermon preached by the Rev. Dr. Tim W. Jensen
at the First Religious Society in Carlisle, Massachusetts
Sunday February 15, 2004
[extemporaneous introduction]
You know, there’s been so much written and said about the subject of Love that sometimes it seems impossible to come up with a fresh approach to the topic. We see it everywhere, talk about it constantly, but do we ever truly understand it? that is, see love as love truly is, rather than simply being swept away head-over-heels by its irresistible power, often when we least expect it...as so many of us have in our lives (and maybe even hope to again). There are so many truisms, so many fantasies and clichés, yet Love the Cliché will lose out to Love the Irresistible Power every time. And even in the fairy tale, it's rarely "happily ever after." No wonder Shakespeare cautions us to "speak low, if you speak love." Clichés do not become clichés by accident, of course; behind each cliché there is a fragment of a larger truth which mere words simply cannot express with the same intensity and freshness as the experience itself. And yet we inevitably struggle to find those words, as if, by giving a name to what we feel, we might just gain a little control over the experience, just as the Miller's daughter gained control of Rumpelstiltskin in that classic fairy tale by the Brothers Grimm.
What is true of Romance is also, in many ways, true of Religion as well. For example, every Sunday morning here at the First Religious Society we stand up and declare proudly that "Love is the Doctrine of this Church." But what do we really mean when we say this? Typically, when I think of Love in a Religious context, my mind is almost immediately drawn to Paul’s famous description in 1st Corinthians 13: "Love is patient; love is kind; love is not envious or boastful or arrogant or rude. It does not insist on is own way; it is not irritable or resentful; it does not rejoice in wrongdoing, but rejoices in the truth. Love bears all things, believes all things, hopes all things, endures all things. Love never ends." Or I’m reminded of the one Great Commandment of both the Gospels and the Hebrew Bible: to love the Lord our God with all our heart, and all our soul, and all our strength, and all our mind, and to love our neighbors as ourselves. Or I may even be tempted to try to make sense of the Scriptural admonition to love my enemies, to "do good to those who hate you, bless those who curse you, pray for those who abuse you"-- perhaps one of the more troubling and problematic edicts of Christian Ethics. And yet, there it is. "For God so loved the world that he gave his only begotten son.... " "Greater Love hath no man than this, that he lay down his life for his friends..." What are we to make of statements like this, in a world where some people are willing to blow themselves up simply to take the lives of a few of their enemies, all in the perceived service of God? And does this somehow in turn justify pre-emptive violence based on fear and suspicion: doing unto others BEFORE they get a chance to do it unto you? Or does Love teach us a better way?
In his famous sermon on "Loving Your Enemies," Martin Luther King Jr. attempted to make sense of these Biblical injunctions by talking about the three different words for love in Ancient Greek: eros, philia, and agape, observing that in each instance it is agape which is elevated to the staring role. King described agape as an "understanding and creative, redemptive goodwill for all" -- a love that empowers us to dwell together in peace. He continued by saying: "An overflowing love which seeks nothing in return, agape is the love of God operating in the human heart. At this level, we love [others] not because we like them, nor because their ways appeal to us, nor even because they possess some type of divine spark; we love [them] because God loves them. At this level, we love the person who does an evil deed, although we hate the deed that [they do]."
Empathy, Compassion, Divine Forgiveness...this is the level at which agape functions. Yet it's often seemed to me that agape love is highly overrated, while eros and philia have gotten something of a bum rap. In the lives of all but the truly saintly, agape rapidly becomes distant and abstract: it lacks the intensity, the immediacy, of the other two types of love. How can we have compassion if passion itself is missing? Where is empathy without a glimmer of understanding?
Erotic love is passionate by nature: intense, immediate, powerful and often irrational. Erotic love frequently manifests itself as the painful hunger to possess, fully and completely, another individual, and to be possessed by them in turn: a union, a mutual joining, a desire to become whole and fulfilled in partnership with someone whose absence makes us suffer, and leaves us feeling fragmented and incomplete, empty and alone. This momentary satisfaction is an illusion, of course: a temporary fusion too intense to be prolonged indefinitely. And yet we crave it with an intensity beyond all other appetites. In the Symposium, Plato has Socrates use the word eros to describe the philosopher's passionate desire for wisdom: a craving, a hunger for the knowledge that will complete us and make us whole, make us one with the truth. When we "seek the truth in love," our search must be a passionate search, our desire for truth something which takes possession of us and drives out all the easy answers and facile explanations: irrational to the extent that it scorns mere rationalization, and satisfied only by a complete and utter union with "The True," however ephemeral it may at first appear.
Philia, on the other hand, is a far more rational form of love. The word is frequently translated as "friendship," but this really doesn't do it justice. Philia is a form of love which grows out of our ability to recognize differences of opinion, of preference, of whatever, and still honor that person's integrity and worth, whether we agree with them or not; or indeed, whether we even like them or not. It's the love which enables us to survive our disagreements, and the ebb and flow of our passions, and ultimately to affirm the power of our common humanity: not God's love "operating in the human heart," but an essentially human love born of our ability to perceive and understand our connectedness, and mutual interdependence, with one another as human beings. And the basis of this friendship, this philia, is not so much Affection as it is Respect.
I think the most articulate description of this I’ve ever heard was Kurt Vonnegut Jr’s Ware Lecture "Love Is Too Strong a Word," which he delivered at the UUA General Assembly in Rochester, New York way back in 1986. (I can’t begin to tell you how hard I had to search to find this again, so I’m going to quote it at some length). But essentially, that evening Vonnegut said to the assembled Unitarian-Universalists (myself included):
***
I will tell you what my theory is: The Christian preachers exhort their listeners to love one another, and to love their neighbors and so on. Love is simply too strong a word to be much use in ordinary, day-to-day relationships. Love is for Romeo and Juliet.
I'm to love my neighbor? How can I do that when I'm not even speaking to my wife and kids today? My wife said to me the other day, after a knock-down, drag-out fight about interior decoration, "I don't love you any more." And I said to her, "So what else is new?" She really didn't love me then, which was perfectly normal. She will love me some other time -- I think, I hope. It's possible.
If she had wanted to terminate the marriage, to carry it past the point of no return, she would have had to say "I don't respect you any more." Now -- that would be terminal.
One of the many unnecessary American catastrophes going on right now...is all the people who are getting divorced because they don't love each other any more. That is like trading in a car when the ashtrays are full. When you don't respect your mate anymore -- that's when the transmission is shot and there's a crack in the engine block.
I like to think that Jesus said in Aramaic, "Ye shall respect one another." That would be a sign to me that he really wanted to help us here on earth, and not just in the afterlife. Then again, he had no way of knowing what ludicrously high standards Hollywood was going to set for love....
And look at the spectrum of emotions we automatically think of when we hear the word "love." If you can't love your neighbors, then you can at least like them. If you can't like them, you can at least not give a damn about them. If you can't ignore them, then you have to hate them, right? You've exhausted all the other possibilities. That's a quick trip to hate, isn't it? And it starts with love. It is such a logical trip, like the one from "white hot" to "ice-cold" with "red hot, hot, warm, tepid, room temperature, cool, chilly, and freezing" in between. The spectrum of emotions suggested by the word "love" again: "love," and then "like," and then "don't give a damn about," and then "hate."
That is my explanation of why hatred is so common in that part of the world dominated by Christianity. There are all these people who have been told to do their best at loving. They fail, most of them. And why wouldn't they fail, since loving is extremely difficult. Most of these people are also failures at pole vaulting and performers on the flying trapeze. And when they fail to love day after day, come one, come all, the logic of the language leads them to the seemingly inevitable conclusion that they must hate instead. The step beyond hating, of course, is killing in imaginary self-defense.
"Ye shall respect one another." Now there is something almost anybody in reasonable mental health can do day after day, year in and year out, come one, come all, to everyone's clear benefit. "Respect" does not imply a spectrum of alternatives, some of them very dangerous. "Respect" is like a light switch. It is either on or off. And if we are no longer able to respect someone, we don't feel like killing him or her. Our response is restrained. We simply want to make him or her feel like something the cat drug in.
Compare making somebody feel like something the cat drug in with Armageddon or World War Three....
***
God’s overflowing love operating in the human heart. The passionate desire to be United-And-Made-One with That-Which-Makes-One-Complete. And Respect for one’s neighbor, (and even for one’s enemy) based on a more fundamental sense of self-respect, whether you “love” that other person or not.
Love manifests itself in our lives, and through our lives, in as many different ways as life itself. God is Love. Love makes the world go round. Love is the Answer (could you please repeat the question?). Or recall the passage I read to open the service: “When I was a child, I spoke like a child, I thought like a child, I reasoned like a child; but when I became an adult, I put an end to childish things. For now we see in a mirror, dimly, but then we will see face to face. Now I know only in part; then I will know fully, even as I have been fully known. And now Faith, Hope, and Love abide -- these three. And the greatest of these is Love.” Think about this for a moment: what does it mean to “know fully, even as one has been fully known” -- to become an adult, to see life, to see one’s beloved, to see the Creator of the Universe, face to face? Maybe this is really what love is all about -- the ability to look into the face of one’s neighbor, or even a stranger, and see one’s beloved reflected there as well, or to look into the face of one’s enemy and recognize that they too were created in the image of God. I can’t really be certain about this, of course; just because I read it in the Bible doesn’t necessarily mean that it’s so. But at the very least it is worth a second look, a closer look. Because who knows what one may see in a mirror, if one looks closely enough.
I also want to point out just one more thing here this morning, which is that the Latin word used to translate the Greek agape in this passage (and many of the others I’ve mentioned here this morning) is caritas, which some of you may recognize from the King James Bible as “charity.” God’s overflowing love operating in the human heart manifests itself in the world as Charity. And charity is more than simply giving assistance to those less fortunate than ourselves. It is a tangible expression of God’s love for us all -- an act of generosity inspired by a feeling of gratitude, which encourages us to share our good fortune with others because we realize that we ourselves have been beneficiaries of God’s many gifts to us in ways that we can never fully repay. And so we learn to express our love of God, and more importantly, our appreciation of God’s love for us, by acting in a loving way toward all of God’s creation. And I know that this is a Unitarian Church, and that there are probably a lot of folks here who don’t even really believe in God, at least in any conventional sense of the word. And that’s perfectly fine, because it doesn’t really matter either. What matters is that God believes in us, and trusts that through the power of love, we will eventually grow to our full potential as kind, loving, generous and understanding human beings -- the very people that God intends for us to be.
“When I was a child, I spoke like a child, I thought like a child, I reasoned like a child; but when I became an adult, I put an end to childish things. For now we see in a mirror, dimly, but then we will see face to face. Now I know only in part; then I will know fully, even as I have been fully known. And now Faith, Hope, and Love abide -- these three. And the greatest of these is Love.” --1st Corinthians 13: 11-13.
If you are proud of this church, become its advocate.
If you are concerned for it future, share its message.
If its values resonate deep within you, give it a measure of your devotion.
Its destiny, the larger hope, rests in your hands.
--Michael A. Schuler
at the First Religious Society in Carlisle, Massachusetts
Sunday February 15, 2004
[extemporaneous introduction]
You know, there’s been so much written and said about the subject of Love that sometimes it seems impossible to come up with a fresh approach to the topic. We see it everywhere, talk about it constantly, but do we ever truly understand it? that is, see love as love truly is, rather than simply being swept away head-over-heels by its irresistible power, often when we least expect it...as so many of us have in our lives (and maybe even hope to again). There are so many truisms, so many fantasies and clichés, yet Love the Cliché will lose out to Love the Irresistible Power every time. And even in the fairy tale, it's rarely "happily ever after." No wonder Shakespeare cautions us to "speak low, if you speak love." Clichés do not become clichés by accident, of course; behind each cliché there is a fragment of a larger truth which mere words simply cannot express with the same intensity and freshness as the experience itself. And yet we inevitably struggle to find those words, as if, by giving a name to what we feel, we might just gain a little control over the experience, just as the Miller's daughter gained control of Rumpelstiltskin in that classic fairy tale by the Brothers Grimm.
What is true of Romance is also, in many ways, true of Religion as well. For example, every Sunday morning here at the First Religious Society we stand up and declare proudly that "Love is the Doctrine of this Church." But what do we really mean when we say this? Typically, when I think of Love in a Religious context, my mind is almost immediately drawn to Paul’s famous description in 1st Corinthians 13: "Love is patient; love is kind; love is not envious or boastful or arrogant or rude. It does not insist on is own way; it is not irritable or resentful; it does not rejoice in wrongdoing, but rejoices in the truth. Love bears all things, believes all things, hopes all things, endures all things. Love never ends." Or I’m reminded of the one Great Commandment of both the Gospels and the Hebrew Bible: to love the Lord our God with all our heart, and all our soul, and all our strength, and all our mind, and to love our neighbors as ourselves. Or I may even be tempted to try to make sense of the Scriptural admonition to love my enemies, to "do good to those who hate you, bless those who curse you, pray for those who abuse you"-- perhaps one of the more troubling and problematic edicts of Christian Ethics. And yet, there it is. "For God so loved the world that he gave his only begotten son.... " "Greater Love hath no man than this, that he lay down his life for his friends..." What are we to make of statements like this, in a world where some people are willing to blow themselves up simply to take the lives of a few of their enemies, all in the perceived service of God? And does this somehow in turn justify pre-emptive violence based on fear and suspicion: doing unto others BEFORE they get a chance to do it unto you? Or does Love teach us a better way?
In his famous sermon on "Loving Your Enemies," Martin Luther King Jr. attempted to make sense of these Biblical injunctions by talking about the three different words for love in Ancient Greek: eros, philia, and agape, observing that in each instance it is agape which is elevated to the staring role. King described agape as an "understanding and creative, redemptive goodwill for all" -- a love that empowers us to dwell together in peace. He continued by saying: "An overflowing love which seeks nothing in return, agape is the love of God operating in the human heart. At this level, we love [others] not because we like them, nor because their ways appeal to us, nor even because they possess some type of divine spark; we love [them] because God loves them. At this level, we love the person who does an evil deed, although we hate the deed that [they do]."
Empathy, Compassion, Divine Forgiveness...this is the level at which agape functions. Yet it's often seemed to me that agape love is highly overrated, while eros and philia have gotten something of a bum rap. In the lives of all but the truly saintly, agape rapidly becomes distant and abstract: it lacks the intensity, the immediacy, of the other two types of love. How can we have compassion if passion itself is missing? Where is empathy without a glimmer of understanding?
Erotic love is passionate by nature: intense, immediate, powerful and often irrational. Erotic love frequently manifests itself as the painful hunger to possess, fully and completely, another individual, and to be possessed by them in turn: a union, a mutual joining, a desire to become whole and fulfilled in partnership with someone whose absence makes us suffer, and leaves us feeling fragmented and incomplete, empty and alone. This momentary satisfaction is an illusion, of course: a temporary fusion too intense to be prolonged indefinitely. And yet we crave it with an intensity beyond all other appetites. In the Symposium, Plato has Socrates use the word eros to describe the philosopher's passionate desire for wisdom: a craving, a hunger for the knowledge that will complete us and make us whole, make us one with the truth. When we "seek the truth in love," our search must be a passionate search, our desire for truth something which takes possession of us and drives out all the easy answers and facile explanations: irrational to the extent that it scorns mere rationalization, and satisfied only by a complete and utter union with "The True," however ephemeral it may at first appear.
Philia, on the other hand, is a far more rational form of love. The word is frequently translated as "friendship," but this really doesn't do it justice. Philia is a form of love which grows out of our ability to recognize differences of opinion, of preference, of whatever, and still honor that person's integrity and worth, whether we agree with them or not; or indeed, whether we even like them or not. It's the love which enables us to survive our disagreements, and the ebb and flow of our passions, and ultimately to affirm the power of our common humanity: not God's love "operating in the human heart," but an essentially human love born of our ability to perceive and understand our connectedness, and mutual interdependence, with one another as human beings. And the basis of this friendship, this philia, is not so much Affection as it is Respect.
I think the most articulate description of this I’ve ever heard was Kurt Vonnegut Jr’s Ware Lecture "Love Is Too Strong a Word," which he delivered at the UUA General Assembly in Rochester, New York way back in 1986. (I can’t begin to tell you how hard I had to search to find this again, so I’m going to quote it at some length). But essentially, that evening Vonnegut said to the assembled Unitarian-Universalists (myself included):
***
I will tell you what my theory is: The Christian preachers exhort their listeners to love one another, and to love their neighbors and so on. Love is simply too strong a word to be much use in ordinary, day-to-day relationships. Love is for Romeo and Juliet.
I'm to love my neighbor? How can I do that when I'm not even speaking to my wife and kids today? My wife said to me the other day, after a knock-down, drag-out fight about interior decoration, "I don't love you any more." And I said to her, "So what else is new?" She really didn't love me then, which was perfectly normal. She will love me some other time -- I think, I hope. It's possible.
If she had wanted to terminate the marriage, to carry it past the point of no return, she would have had to say "I don't respect you any more." Now -- that would be terminal.
One of the many unnecessary American catastrophes going on right now...is all the people who are getting divorced because they don't love each other any more. That is like trading in a car when the ashtrays are full. When you don't respect your mate anymore -- that's when the transmission is shot and there's a crack in the engine block.
I like to think that Jesus said in Aramaic, "Ye shall respect one another." That would be a sign to me that he really wanted to help us here on earth, and not just in the afterlife. Then again, he had no way of knowing what ludicrously high standards Hollywood was going to set for love....
And look at the spectrum of emotions we automatically think of when we hear the word "love." If you can't love your neighbors, then you can at least like them. If you can't like them, you can at least not give a damn about them. If you can't ignore them, then you have to hate them, right? You've exhausted all the other possibilities. That's a quick trip to hate, isn't it? And it starts with love. It is such a logical trip, like the one from "white hot" to "ice-cold" with "red hot, hot, warm, tepid, room temperature, cool, chilly, and freezing" in between. The spectrum of emotions suggested by the word "love" again: "love," and then "like," and then "don't give a damn about," and then "hate."
That is my explanation of why hatred is so common in that part of the world dominated by Christianity. There are all these people who have been told to do their best at loving. They fail, most of them. And why wouldn't they fail, since loving is extremely difficult. Most of these people are also failures at pole vaulting and performers on the flying trapeze. And when they fail to love day after day, come one, come all, the logic of the language leads them to the seemingly inevitable conclusion that they must hate instead. The step beyond hating, of course, is killing in imaginary self-defense.
"Ye shall respect one another." Now there is something almost anybody in reasonable mental health can do day after day, year in and year out, come one, come all, to everyone's clear benefit. "Respect" does not imply a spectrum of alternatives, some of them very dangerous. "Respect" is like a light switch. It is either on or off. And if we are no longer able to respect someone, we don't feel like killing him or her. Our response is restrained. We simply want to make him or her feel like something the cat drug in.
Compare making somebody feel like something the cat drug in with Armageddon or World War Three....
***
God’s overflowing love operating in the human heart. The passionate desire to be United-And-Made-One with That-Which-Makes-One-Complete. And Respect for one’s neighbor, (and even for one’s enemy) based on a more fundamental sense of self-respect, whether you “love” that other person or not.
Love manifests itself in our lives, and through our lives, in as many different ways as life itself. God is Love. Love makes the world go round. Love is the Answer (could you please repeat the question?). Or recall the passage I read to open the service: “When I was a child, I spoke like a child, I thought like a child, I reasoned like a child; but when I became an adult, I put an end to childish things. For now we see in a mirror, dimly, but then we will see face to face. Now I know only in part; then I will know fully, even as I have been fully known. And now Faith, Hope, and Love abide -- these three. And the greatest of these is Love.” Think about this for a moment: what does it mean to “know fully, even as one has been fully known” -- to become an adult, to see life, to see one’s beloved, to see the Creator of the Universe, face to face? Maybe this is really what love is all about -- the ability to look into the face of one’s neighbor, or even a stranger, and see one’s beloved reflected there as well, or to look into the face of one’s enemy and recognize that they too were created in the image of God. I can’t really be certain about this, of course; just because I read it in the Bible doesn’t necessarily mean that it’s so. But at the very least it is worth a second look, a closer look. Because who knows what one may see in a mirror, if one looks closely enough.
I also want to point out just one more thing here this morning, which is that the Latin word used to translate the Greek agape in this passage (and many of the others I’ve mentioned here this morning) is caritas, which some of you may recognize from the King James Bible as “charity.” God’s overflowing love operating in the human heart manifests itself in the world as Charity. And charity is more than simply giving assistance to those less fortunate than ourselves. It is a tangible expression of God’s love for us all -- an act of generosity inspired by a feeling of gratitude, which encourages us to share our good fortune with others because we realize that we ourselves have been beneficiaries of God’s many gifts to us in ways that we can never fully repay. And so we learn to express our love of God, and more importantly, our appreciation of God’s love for us, by acting in a loving way toward all of God’s creation. And I know that this is a Unitarian Church, and that there are probably a lot of folks here who don’t even really believe in God, at least in any conventional sense of the word. And that’s perfectly fine, because it doesn’t really matter either. What matters is that God believes in us, and trusts that through the power of love, we will eventually grow to our full potential as kind, loving, generous and understanding human beings -- the very people that God intends for us to be.
“When I was a child, I spoke like a child, I thought like a child, I reasoned like a child; but when I became an adult, I put an end to childish things. For now we see in a mirror, dimly, but then we will see face to face. Now I know only in part; then I will know fully, even as I have been fully known. And now Faith, Hope, and Love abide -- these three. And the greatest of these is Love.” --1st Corinthians 13: 11-13.
If you are proud of this church, become its advocate.
If you are concerned for it future, share its message.
If its values resonate deep within you, give it a measure of your devotion.
Its destiny, the larger hope, rests in your hands.
--Michael A. Schuler
Sunday, January 25, 2004
YOUR GUESS IS AS GOOD AS MINE
a sermon preached by the Rev. Dr. Tim W. Jensen
at the First Religious Society in Carlisle, Massachusetts
Sunday January 25th, 2004
I was having a little trouble figuring out what I wanted to talk about this week. It wasn’t that I lacked inspiration; if anything, just the opposite -- I had too MUCH inspiration, too many things going on in the world, too many good ideas, all of which deserved fuller exploration and explication. Harry Emerson Fosdick once said that the modern preacher needed to enter the pulpit with a Bible in one hand and a newspaper in the other, but even if I just stuck to the headlines it’s hard to know where to begin. Last week’s Iowa Caucuses, next week’s New Hampshire primary, and sandwiched between them, like the rich, creamy middle of an Oreo cookie, the State of the Union Address...and that’s just the timely political stuff. We’ve also got robots on Mars (evocatively named “Spirit” and “Opportunity”), the Patriots are headed for the Super Bowl, and then there are always timeless themes like peace and prosperity, justice and compassion, honesty, integrity, generosity, forgiveness...all of which have received ample illustration, both positive and negative, in recent days, as they do almost every day. There’s so much, it’s hard to know where to begin.
One thing though that has been on my mind quite a bit of late is something that Woody initially brought to my attention. In the most recent issue of The Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion, there is a comprehensive sociological examination of “Clergy as Political Activists,” which runs well over 100 pages, and reviews the political behavior of clergy across the theological spectrum in the 2000 Presidential election. There are articles surveying both evangelical and mainline Protestant ministers, Catholic Priests, Rabbis and African American ministers, and we Unitarian Universalists even get an article all to ourselves. “Clergy are well positioned to influence others politically,” the study found, because they “tend to be respected both individually and collectively,...are generally perceived to be spiritual and moral leaders who are likely to be attentive to the moral conditions of the world around them, and finally...[they] are generally well educated and engage in more ideological thinking than those with fewer years of schooling.” Well, that all sounded familiar enough; but the most interesting revelation of the study was the extent to which conservative, evangelical Christian pastors now match their more liberal brethren in their levels of political activism.
Historically, mainline Protestant churches have been deeply influenced by a movement known as the Social Gospel, a “theological perspective that stresses structural reform, [and] not just spiritual conversion and personal sanctification, as the means for social change,” and likewise “implies a need for pastors to become politically involved in order to help the less fortunate.” The theology of the Social Gospel served as one of the main inspirations for the Civil Rights movement of the 1950’s, the Peace movement of the 1960’s, the Environmental and Women’s Rights movements of the 1970’s, the Sanctuary and Nuclear Freeze movements of the 1980’s, the anti-Globalization and Economic Justice movements of the 1990’s, and it continues to exert a powerful influence over the social justice ministries of mainline denominations today -- not just for Unitarian Universalists, but also for Methodists, Episcopalians, Congregationalists, Presbyterians, Quakers, Lutherans, American Baptists, the Disciples of Christ, even many Reformed Jews and liberal Roman Catholics.
But over this same period of time, there have been two other interesting developments in American society. The first is that political liberals have grown increasingly disillusioned with religious institutions as vehicles for achieving social change. There are a lot of different reasons for this, but the main one, it seems to me, is that Churches tend to move “at the speed of Church” -- we are far too process-oriented, far too interested in achieving consensus before taking any action, to satisfy most Activists, and thus liberal/progressive politics in this country have become increasingly secular in the last half-century, so much so that pollsters now say that Church attendance has become one of the leading indicators of one’s political sympathies among American voters.
This brings us to the second development, which is that over the past two decades or so religious conservatives have become far more politically active than they were a generation ago. Much of this is due to the efforts of national organizations like the Christian Coalition, the Moral Majority, and Focus on the Family, and it almost goes without saying that this activism takes a far different shape from that of liberals. The activism of religious conservatives tends to be focused on issues of “moral reform” -- advocacy of things like prayer in public schools and support for “traditional family values,” opposition to things like abortion and civil unions. And it is centered around a set of beliefs sociologists call “the Civic Gospel,” which goes something like this: “The United States was founded as a Christian nation; Free Enterprise is the only economic system truly compatible with Christian beliefs; Religious values are under attack in contemporary America; Government needs to act in order to protect the nation’s religious heritage; there is only one Christian view on most political issues, and...it is hard for political liberals to be true Christians.”
I’ll doubtlessly return to this material again in more detail at some time in the future, since I find it fascinating and have only begun to scratch the surface of it, but the point I want to make today is that much of the bitter acrimony and political polarization we are experiencing in our country right now is, at bottom, a conflict between two very different understandings of what it means to be religious. It’s more than just a difference of opinion about policy options. Rather, it’s about two fundamentally contradictory world views, which sometimes use the same words, but in many ways are speaking entirely different languages: a conflict between a spirituality based on tolerance and mutual understanding, which sees all human beings as brothers and sisters created in the image of God, and thus embraces an ethic of pluralism and diversity, and a more rigid style of faith which often times views pluralism and diversity as intolerable violations of God’s Law, which “the faithful” are morally obligated to punish and suppress.
And I’ll tell you right now, I don’t know what the solution is. My faith tells me that if we all just do a little more talking with one another, eventually we’ll arrive at some sort of mutual understanding and a shared sense of purpose...but my experience says that the other side isn’t really interested in what I have to say...they’ve already made up their minds, and are basically willing to do or say whatever it takes in order to get their way. They’ll promise us the moon, tell us things they know aren’t true, spend money they no longer have to punish their enemies and reward their friends. And it all just leave me feeling frustrated, and not particularly tolerant or understanding. And yet, the irony of my situation is not entirely lost on me. I never really understood, until this President came to power, what the “vast, right wing conspiracy” of Clinton-haters was really all about. But now I kinda get it, and I even feel a little sorry for them...having to suffer through eight years of a leader they didn’t respect, and whom they felt didn’t deserve the high office that had been entrusted to him. When the mere sight of someone’s face, or even the sound of their voice, is enough to make you feel physically angry, you are stuck in an extremely unpleasant predicament -- which may be all the more reason for you not to like them, but also does little to help you get out of it. And while ranting and venting may make you feel good for awhile, in the long run what’s the point of haranguing the folks around you about something they aren’t really responsible for, and can’t actually do anything to change anyway? And it also occurs to me, as an historian, that there were people who felt this way about FDR -- the original “that man in the White House” -- and others who felt so strongly about Lincoln that they actually dropped out of the country and started a war of rebellion. And this, perhaps, is the greatest irony of all: that it is the descendants of the people whom Lincoln defeated who now control the political party he helped to create, and who are using their newly-found political power to dismantle as much of the New Deal as they can, ignoring the fact that in many cases it was their parents and grandparents who were the principal beneficiaries of it.
Sometimes politics appear to be about issues of policy -- specific steps that need to be taken in order to address particular problems. And sometimes politics appear to be about leadership: questions of character, vision, and personal integrity. But beyond leadership, beyond policy, are the more fundamental concerns of Peace and Prosperity, and whether or not the benefits of a peaceful and prosperous society are going to be broadly shared among the many, or narrowly concentrated in the hands of just a few. Are freedom and justice, education and health care, food, clothing and shelter, only for the wealthy, the privileged and fortunate, even the morally-deserving? Or should they be distributed as widely as possible, and as equally as equity will permit? What should a society do with its surplus, once the basic needs of its members have been met? Should it be invested for the public good? Saved for a rainy day? Left in the hands of private individuals, because they’ve “earned” it? Used to create art, music, literature, perhaps simply leisure itself? Or should it be given as charity to widows and orphans, the homeless and the less-fortunate, whether they “deserve” it or not? And who gets to decide, and how do these decisions get made? -- by everyone concerned, in an open and public forum, or merely by a handful of the most powerful and influential, and behind closed doors? These are not just political issues; they are also religious issues, involving fundamental questions of fairness and compassion, of right and wrong. The answers may seem obvious to you; I think they seem obvious to almost everyone, until we meet someone who sees things differently. And so the discussion begins again, from a slightly different perspective.
I don’t want to try to repeat here on Sunday morning things you can easily hear or read elsewhere. And I don’t think it really matters whether or not you know which candidates I’m going to support (or not support), or how I feel about specific issues, or even larger questions of public policy. I can’t imagine that it would be too hard to figure out, but it’s also beside the point -- because the real challenge is not to persuade you all to think just like me, but rather to get you to look at your own opinions from a slightly different perspective, until you’re certain you know both what and WHY you believe. And my main mantra for the fall is simply going to be "a free and fair election in which everyone who can vote does vote, and every vote gets counted." How can we possibly claim to be exporting Democracy to the rest of the world when we don't even practice it here at home?
Instead of a Constitutional Amendment to protect the sanctity of marriage, how about one eliminating the archaic Electoral College, and (while we’re at it) making election day a national holiday? Or if we are truly interested in dramatic electoral reform, we could institute proportional state-by-state representation in the House, thus putting an end to partisan gerrymandering once and for all. In the last Congressional election, only four challengers defeated incumbent Congressmen, and according to the New York Times, of the 435 seats in the House of Representatives, this year there may be as few as 30 where the outcome is truly in doubt. In Pennsylvania, there are half-a-million more registered Democrats that there are Republicans, yet Pennsylvania’s Congressional delegation with 12 Republicans and just 7 Democrats. Add in Florida, Ohio and Michigan, and the Republican Congressional advantage swells to nearly two-to-one, although the numbers of Democratic and Republican voters in these states are almost exactly equal. Proportional representation would mean the each political party would present a slate of candidates for the entire state, and representatives would be elected based on the percentage of votes polled by each party. Not only would it more fairly allocate representation according to the number of each party’s supporters, it would also make it slightly easier for minor party candidates to win election, once their support rises to a certain threshold.
I don’t actually expect any of these things to happen, of course. We’ve done things the way we’ve done them for so long, that even when it’s broken we are reluctant to try to fix it. Yet when the margin of victory in a national election is less than the margin of error, or when the winning candidate can poll fewer votes than the losing candidate and still claim victory, or when the outcome of an election is never in doubt in the first place, because the rules have been written in such a way that it is next to impossible for a challenger to defeat an incumbent, democracy itself is in danger. And this kind of threat to our freedom is far more serious than anything posed by foreign terrorists, since it strikes not just at buildings, but at the heart of our society itself. And we defend against it, not with soldiers and weapons, but with our own good hearts, and our willingness to stand up and say what we truly believe.
Top Ten Ways I, Howard Dean, Can Turn Things Around
10. "Switch to decaf"
9. "Unveil new slogan: 'Vote for Dean and get one dollar off you next purchase at Blimpie'"
8. "Marry Rachel on final episode of 'Friends'"
7. "Don't change a thing -- it's going great"
6. "Show a little more skin"
5. "Go on 'American Idol' and give 'em a taste of these pipes"
4. "Start working out and speaking with Austrian accent"
3. "I can't give specifics yet, but it involves Ted Danson"
2. "Fire the staffer who suggested we do this lousy Top Ten list instead of actually campaigning"
1. "Oh, I don't know -- maybe fewer crazy, redfaced rants"
at the First Religious Society in Carlisle, Massachusetts
Sunday January 25th, 2004
I was having a little trouble figuring out what I wanted to talk about this week. It wasn’t that I lacked inspiration; if anything, just the opposite -- I had too MUCH inspiration, too many things going on in the world, too many good ideas, all of which deserved fuller exploration and explication. Harry Emerson Fosdick once said that the modern preacher needed to enter the pulpit with a Bible in one hand and a newspaper in the other, but even if I just stuck to the headlines it’s hard to know where to begin. Last week’s Iowa Caucuses, next week’s New Hampshire primary, and sandwiched between them, like the rich, creamy middle of an Oreo cookie, the State of the Union Address...and that’s just the timely political stuff. We’ve also got robots on Mars (evocatively named “Spirit” and “Opportunity”), the Patriots are headed for the Super Bowl, and then there are always timeless themes like peace and prosperity, justice and compassion, honesty, integrity, generosity, forgiveness...all of which have received ample illustration, both positive and negative, in recent days, as they do almost every day. There’s so much, it’s hard to know where to begin.
One thing though that has been on my mind quite a bit of late is something that Woody initially brought to my attention. In the most recent issue of The Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion, there is a comprehensive sociological examination of “Clergy as Political Activists,” which runs well over 100 pages, and reviews the political behavior of clergy across the theological spectrum in the 2000 Presidential election. There are articles surveying both evangelical and mainline Protestant ministers, Catholic Priests, Rabbis and African American ministers, and we Unitarian Universalists even get an article all to ourselves. “Clergy are well positioned to influence others politically,” the study found, because they “tend to be respected both individually and collectively,...are generally perceived to be spiritual and moral leaders who are likely to be attentive to the moral conditions of the world around them, and finally...[they] are generally well educated and engage in more ideological thinking than those with fewer years of schooling.” Well, that all sounded familiar enough; but the most interesting revelation of the study was the extent to which conservative, evangelical Christian pastors now match their more liberal brethren in their levels of political activism.
Historically, mainline Protestant churches have been deeply influenced by a movement known as the Social Gospel, a “theological perspective that stresses structural reform, [and] not just spiritual conversion and personal sanctification, as the means for social change,” and likewise “implies a need for pastors to become politically involved in order to help the less fortunate.” The theology of the Social Gospel served as one of the main inspirations for the Civil Rights movement of the 1950’s, the Peace movement of the 1960’s, the Environmental and Women’s Rights movements of the 1970’s, the Sanctuary and Nuclear Freeze movements of the 1980’s, the anti-Globalization and Economic Justice movements of the 1990’s, and it continues to exert a powerful influence over the social justice ministries of mainline denominations today -- not just for Unitarian Universalists, but also for Methodists, Episcopalians, Congregationalists, Presbyterians, Quakers, Lutherans, American Baptists, the Disciples of Christ, even many Reformed Jews and liberal Roman Catholics.
But over this same period of time, there have been two other interesting developments in American society. The first is that political liberals have grown increasingly disillusioned with religious institutions as vehicles for achieving social change. There are a lot of different reasons for this, but the main one, it seems to me, is that Churches tend to move “at the speed of Church” -- we are far too process-oriented, far too interested in achieving consensus before taking any action, to satisfy most Activists, and thus liberal/progressive politics in this country have become increasingly secular in the last half-century, so much so that pollsters now say that Church attendance has become one of the leading indicators of one’s political sympathies among American voters.
This brings us to the second development, which is that over the past two decades or so religious conservatives have become far more politically active than they were a generation ago. Much of this is due to the efforts of national organizations like the Christian Coalition, the Moral Majority, and Focus on the Family, and it almost goes without saying that this activism takes a far different shape from that of liberals. The activism of religious conservatives tends to be focused on issues of “moral reform” -- advocacy of things like prayer in public schools and support for “traditional family values,” opposition to things like abortion and civil unions. And it is centered around a set of beliefs sociologists call “the Civic Gospel,” which goes something like this: “The United States was founded as a Christian nation; Free Enterprise is the only economic system truly compatible with Christian beliefs; Religious values are under attack in contemporary America; Government needs to act in order to protect the nation’s religious heritage; there is only one Christian view on most political issues, and...it is hard for political liberals to be true Christians.”
I’ll doubtlessly return to this material again in more detail at some time in the future, since I find it fascinating and have only begun to scratch the surface of it, but the point I want to make today is that much of the bitter acrimony and political polarization we are experiencing in our country right now is, at bottom, a conflict between two very different understandings of what it means to be religious. It’s more than just a difference of opinion about policy options. Rather, it’s about two fundamentally contradictory world views, which sometimes use the same words, but in many ways are speaking entirely different languages: a conflict between a spirituality based on tolerance and mutual understanding, which sees all human beings as brothers and sisters created in the image of God, and thus embraces an ethic of pluralism and diversity, and a more rigid style of faith which often times views pluralism and diversity as intolerable violations of God’s Law, which “the faithful” are morally obligated to punish and suppress.
And I’ll tell you right now, I don’t know what the solution is. My faith tells me that if we all just do a little more talking with one another, eventually we’ll arrive at some sort of mutual understanding and a shared sense of purpose...but my experience says that the other side isn’t really interested in what I have to say...they’ve already made up their minds, and are basically willing to do or say whatever it takes in order to get their way. They’ll promise us the moon, tell us things they know aren’t true, spend money they no longer have to punish their enemies and reward their friends. And it all just leave me feeling frustrated, and not particularly tolerant or understanding. And yet, the irony of my situation is not entirely lost on me. I never really understood, until this President came to power, what the “vast, right wing conspiracy” of Clinton-haters was really all about. But now I kinda get it, and I even feel a little sorry for them...having to suffer through eight years of a leader they didn’t respect, and whom they felt didn’t deserve the high office that had been entrusted to him. When the mere sight of someone’s face, or even the sound of their voice, is enough to make you feel physically angry, you are stuck in an extremely unpleasant predicament -- which may be all the more reason for you not to like them, but also does little to help you get out of it. And while ranting and venting may make you feel good for awhile, in the long run what’s the point of haranguing the folks around you about something they aren’t really responsible for, and can’t actually do anything to change anyway? And it also occurs to me, as an historian, that there were people who felt this way about FDR -- the original “that man in the White House” -- and others who felt so strongly about Lincoln that they actually dropped out of the country and started a war of rebellion. And this, perhaps, is the greatest irony of all: that it is the descendants of the people whom Lincoln defeated who now control the political party he helped to create, and who are using their newly-found political power to dismantle as much of the New Deal as they can, ignoring the fact that in many cases it was their parents and grandparents who were the principal beneficiaries of it.
Sometimes politics appear to be about issues of policy -- specific steps that need to be taken in order to address particular problems. And sometimes politics appear to be about leadership: questions of character, vision, and personal integrity. But beyond leadership, beyond policy, are the more fundamental concerns of Peace and Prosperity, and whether or not the benefits of a peaceful and prosperous society are going to be broadly shared among the many, or narrowly concentrated in the hands of just a few. Are freedom and justice, education and health care, food, clothing and shelter, only for the wealthy, the privileged and fortunate, even the morally-deserving? Or should they be distributed as widely as possible, and as equally as equity will permit? What should a society do with its surplus, once the basic needs of its members have been met? Should it be invested for the public good? Saved for a rainy day? Left in the hands of private individuals, because they’ve “earned” it? Used to create art, music, literature, perhaps simply leisure itself? Or should it be given as charity to widows and orphans, the homeless and the less-fortunate, whether they “deserve” it or not? And who gets to decide, and how do these decisions get made? -- by everyone concerned, in an open and public forum, or merely by a handful of the most powerful and influential, and behind closed doors? These are not just political issues; they are also religious issues, involving fundamental questions of fairness and compassion, of right and wrong. The answers may seem obvious to you; I think they seem obvious to almost everyone, until we meet someone who sees things differently. And so the discussion begins again, from a slightly different perspective.
I don’t want to try to repeat here on Sunday morning things you can easily hear or read elsewhere. And I don’t think it really matters whether or not you know which candidates I’m going to support (or not support), or how I feel about specific issues, or even larger questions of public policy. I can’t imagine that it would be too hard to figure out, but it’s also beside the point -- because the real challenge is not to persuade you all to think just like me, but rather to get you to look at your own opinions from a slightly different perspective, until you’re certain you know both what and WHY you believe. And my main mantra for the fall is simply going to be "a free and fair election in which everyone who can vote does vote, and every vote gets counted." How can we possibly claim to be exporting Democracy to the rest of the world when we don't even practice it here at home?
Instead of a Constitutional Amendment to protect the sanctity of marriage, how about one eliminating the archaic Electoral College, and (while we’re at it) making election day a national holiday? Or if we are truly interested in dramatic electoral reform, we could institute proportional state-by-state representation in the House, thus putting an end to partisan gerrymandering once and for all. In the last Congressional election, only four challengers defeated incumbent Congressmen, and according to the New York Times, of the 435 seats in the House of Representatives, this year there may be as few as 30 where the outcome is truly in doubt. In Pennsylvania, there are half-a-million more registered Democrats that there are Republicans, yet Pennsylvania’s Congressional delegation with 12 Republicans and just 7 Democrats. Add in Florida, Ohio and Michigan, and the Republican Congressional advantage swells to nearly two-to-one, although the numbers of Democratic and Republican voters in these states are almost exactly equal. Proportional representation would mean the each political party would present a slate of candidates for the entire state, and representatives would be elected based on the percentage of votes polled by each party. Not only would it more fairly allocate representation according to the number of each party’s supporters, it would also make it slightly easier for minor party candidates to win election, once their support rises to a certain threshold.
I don’t actually expect any of these things to happen, of course. We’ve done things the way we’ve done them for so long, that even when it’s broken we are reluctant to try to fix it. Yet when the margin of victory in a national election is less than the margin of error, or when the winning candidate can poll fewer votes than the losing candidate and still claim victory, or when the outcome of an election is never in doubt in the first place, because the rules have been written in such a way that it is next to impossible for a challenger to defeat an incumbent, democracy itself is in danger. And this kind of threat to our freedom is far more serious than anything posed by foreign terrorists, since it strikes not just at buildings, but at the heart of our society itself. And we defend against it, not with soldiers and weapons, but with our own good hearts, and our willingness to stand up and say what we truly believe.
Top Ten Ways I, Howard Dean, Can Turn Things Around
10. "Switch to decaf"
9. "Unveil new slogan: 'Vote for Dean and get one dollar off you next purchase at Blimpie'"
8. "Marry Rachel on final episode of 'Friends'"
7. "Don't change a thing -- it's going great"
6. "Show a little more skin"
5. "Go on 'American Idol' and give 'em a taste of these pipes"
4. "Start working out and speaking with Austrian accent"
3. "I can't give specifics yet, but it involves Ted Danson"
2. "Fire the staffer who suggested we do this lousy Top Ten list instead of actually campaigning"
1. "Oh, I don't know -- maybe fewer crazy, redfaced rants"
Sunday, January 18, 2004
THE STRENGTH TO LOVE
a sermon preached by the Rev. Dr. Tim W. Jensen
at the First Religious Society in Carlisle, Massachusetts
Sunday January 18th, 2004
I once saw an interview with the actor Ben Kingsley, who casually observed that the secret to his successful characterization of Mohandas Gandhi in the renown Richard Attenbourgh film of the same name, was his realization that Gandhi was not so much a saint who "stooped" to participate in politics as he was a politician struggling to become a saint. I've thought about that apparently offhand remark a great deal since first hearing it. Why is it that professional politicians are so universally held in such low esteem in our society, so much so that even honest-to-God “saintly” individuals (like, say, Jimmy Carter) inevitably appear "compromised" in the public eye when they attempt to participate in the political process? It reminds me of a story I once heard about the syndicated advice columnist Ann Landers, who was approached one evening by a member of the Senate at an Embassy Reception in Washington D.C.
"So you're Ann Landers," the Senator remarked. "Say something funny."
To which Ms Landers immediately responded "So you're a politician. Tell me a lie."
Political activity is the lifeblood of a free society; it is the means by which the will of the people becomes the law of the land. We lift up American Democracy as a model for all the world, yet for some reason we find it all too easy to believe that those who choose to practice politics as a vocation must be doing so from base motives, avariciously, deceitfully, with only their own advancement rather than the best interests of the country or even their own constituents at heart. It’s almost as though we believe that true saints must somehow be "above politics" -- unsullied by the strange bedfellows encountered in smoke-filled cloakrooms. Fools rush in where Angels fear to tread; and Saints, of course, are expected to behave like angels. Politicians on the other hand, remain free to behave like fools.
Of course, it’s not as if the politicians themselves don’t do plenty to bring on this sort of criticism. It’s almost enough to convert even a naive, wide-eyed optimistic Idealist like myself into a confirmed cynic. The events of this past week have been particularly egregious in this regard. While the Democrats were out west in Iowa engaging in their usual round-robin of mutual recrimination, insinuation, and name-calling known as a “Caucus,” the President flew to Atlanta to lay a wreath on the memorial of Martin Luther King Jr. (thus allowing him to bill the taxpayers for his travel), then rode across town to a $2000/plate fundraising dinner (where he raised more money in a single evening than the most credible African-American candidate, Carol Mosely Braun, raised during her entire campaign), after which he returned to Washington DC to announce a trillion-dollar program to send a man to Mars (most of which, if it is actually ever appropriated, will be spent in Texas and Florida: two states critical to the President’s re-election, and notorious for their efforts to circumvent the Voting Rights Act), and that incidentally, since Congress is now in recess, he is going to exercise his “emergency powers” under the Constitution to appoint Charles Pickering to the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, despite the fact that the controversial Judge had already failed twice to win Senate confirmation, and was opposed (because of his judicial record) by essentially every important Civil Rights organization in the country, including Dr. King’s own Southern Christian Leadership Conference. But Pickering is popular with the Religious Right because of his views on abortion, among other things, thus making his recess appointment a perfect opportunity for both parties to pander sanctimoniously to “the Faithful,” portraying themselves as the last bold defenders of all that is Good, and Moral, and True in our society, while characterizing their opponents as Evil Incarnate. Just to be fair, guess where Howard Dean is attending church this morning? That’s right, in Plains Georgia with Jimmy Carter. And don’t even get me started on all the self-righteous double-talk about civil unions, and the so-called “Healthy Marriage Initiative.”
But confronted with things like this, what are we then to think about that rare politician, like a Mohandas Gandhi, who truly does struggle to become a saint -- who seeks to express through his or her political convictions the high ethical and humanitarian principles of a profound religious faith? Actually, despite my own evolving cynicism, I suspect that this sort of politician is far more common than we generally assume, and that our appreciation of their efforts depends to a great extent upon the degree to which our own political opinions are in agreement with theirs. The road to sainthood is long and arduous, and the dividing line between “saint” and “fanatic” typically razor-thin; many are called but few are chosen; ultimately only history will decide whether or not the struggle was fruitful. Sainthood and the aspiration to sainthood are hardly one and the same. Indeed, so rarefied is our view of the former that often merely the ambition to attain it is enough to taint its purity in our eyes. Yet it would be equally misleading to assume that only those who do not seek it, who have their greatness thrust upon them, are somehow deserving of the mantle of our respect. The inner quality of sainthood is a peculiar combination of humility and arrogance: the arrogance to believe that one's deeply held principles and convictions are important enough to make a difference, and the humility to recognize that this challenge cannot be met by aspiration and strength of will alone.
Martin Luther King Jr. was only 26 years old when he was elected president of the Montgomery Improvement Association, an ad hoc black community group which had been organized to oversee the now famous Montgomery Bus Boycott. As best I can tell, judging from everything I have read, he probably didn't even want the job. At the time, King had been pastor of the Dexter Avenue Baptist Church for less than two years, and had only completed the final requirements for his Ph.D. at Boston University that previous spring. Furthermore, his selection as President of the M.I.A. was an overtly political choice. As a relative newcomer to the city of Montgomery, King had yet to become too strongly identified with any particular element within the black community, and thus it was felt that perhaps he could provide precisely the kind of neutral leadership which would allow all of the rival factions within that community to come together in this one common purpose. There was a downside consideration to his nomination as well. Should the boycott fail, as many of the more experienced black community leaders believed it might, this young preacher could easily be sacrificed without endangering these more established leaders' hard earned credibility with both the white establishment, and their own constituencies.
Knowing this aspect of the story, one might easily say that Martin Luther King Jr. did indeed have his greatness thrust upon him, and with the unanimous consent of older, wiser, and more politically savvy colleagues at that. But clearly, this would be only part of the tale. More importantly, there was an inner quality to this aspiring but untested religious leader, an intrinsic quality of saintliness if you will, which, once exposed, blossomed forth into a strength which enabled him to endure receiving dozens of threatening letters and telephone calls each day; to survive slander and harassment by police and other government authorities; to have the front of his parsonage blown off by dynamite while his wife and few-month-old child huddled in the kitchen...to experience all of the doubts and fears and pressures to which the human soul is vulnerable, and still not lose sight of the larger aspiration: a goal which in its very rightness and importance dwarfed both his abilities, and his frailties, as a human being.
To be sure, in many ways Martin Luther King Jr. did have his greatness thrust upon him: he happened to be in the right place, at the right time. But the reason we honor him with a national holiday on his birthday is because he also happened to be the right person to be there in Montgomery, Alabama in 1955, when Rosa Parks refused to give up her seat on a bus. Yes, there was an inner quality of greatness to him. But more importantly, he did not shy from his responsibilities when the need to express that greatness presented itself before him.
From Montgomery, as we all know, King went on to face new challenges and achieve new triumphs: in Birmingham and Selma, in Washington D.C. and Oslo, Norway, where he became the youngest man ever to receive a Nobel Peace prize. Yet I've often wondered whether or not King's greatest challenge and achievement might not have been related to the conflicts which he faced within his own soul, such as the temptation to "retire" as it were from the Civil Rights movement, and accept a lucrative post somewhere in academia, or to spend more time with his wife and his children, away from the death threats and the FBI wiretaps; to grow old in the bosom of the liberal white establishment, lecturing to wide-eyed freshmen about Socrates and Jesus, Gandhi and Thoreau, while writing bestselling books for Harper and Row.
These options were certainly made available to him many times. And yet he chose instead to continue to fill that role which destiny had thrust upon him there in Montgomery in 1955; and this, to me, seems a far more telling mark of King's true "saintly greatness" than any of his other achievements or laurels. It is not merely because King achieved great things that we celebrate his birth as a National holiday. It is also the price he was willing to pay in order to achieve these things -- not for his own personal benefit, but for the benefit of an entire society.
It is difficult for those of us who lack this inner quality of saintliness, this peculiar combination of humility and arrogance,to fully understand what was at stake in Martin Luther King Jr's decision to continue along the path that had been chosen for him, a path which eventually led him to his death on a motel balcony in Memphis. There have been those who have claimed that King was, in fact, a megalomaniac, or that he suffered from a "martyr complex," that his ego was such that he simply could not step out of the national limelight once he had tasted the sweetness of being Time magazine's "Man of the Year."
Nothing, I think, could be further from the truth.
King himself knew better than anyone what was at stake in the drama that was being played out in his frail, mortal human existence. And he spoke of it simply in terms of "The Strength to Love:" the power of God's own overflowing, passionate, creative love for human kind manifesting itself in a single human life. Perhaps it was a form of megalomania, a delusion of grandeur of the most grandiose proportions. But it was also an ultimate act of personal surrender, a martyrdom of the self in the truest sense of that word, as a witness to a creative power for justice far greater than one's own power or creativity.
In the final analysis we must recognize that it was not delusion, but vision, which animated King's career as a civil rights reformer. Commentator Gary Wills has noted that the changes which Martin Luther King Jr. brought to American society were "so large as to be almost invisible." In a few short years, King and those who worked with him swept away an entire system of American apartheid which had existed in the South for nearly a century. Men and women of my generation have had no experience of "whites only" lunch counters, restrooms, and drinking fountains; we have been educated in integrated schools, voted for and elected black politicians, patronized black-owned businesses; and, for the most part, we have done so without giving it second thought.
This is not to say that racial prejudice and discrimination no longer exist in this country. White Sheets and cross-burnings may seem like things of the past, but we still have hate crimes in this country; the Ku Klux Klan is still alive and kicking, and has spawned numerous imitators; access to jobs, housing, justice, health care, educational opportunity is still not completely color blind, nor anywhere near equally available to all. In many ways racism has become much more subtle, even sophisticated; it has replaced its white sheets with pinstriped suits, and is fueled as much by the ignorance and the naivete of the well-intentioned (who would just as soon not think about it, and who wish that the problem would simply "go away"), as it is by the malice of those few (albeit increasingly vocal) kooks who would just as soon trot segregation (or its functional equivalent) back out of the closet, if they thought they could get away with it.
Yet King's vision of a truly pluralistic, inclusive, and democratic society, in which individuals are judged by the quality of their characters and not the color of their skins, remains a vivid beacon of our future, untarnished in the nearly half-century which has now elapsed since the bus boycott in Montgomery, which first brought this man to our national attention.
It’s a little-known fact, but my ex-wife Margaret and I were married in Atlanta: at midnight on the Summer Solstice at the Peachtree Plaza hotel during the UUA General Assembly in 1985. It was the first time either of us had ever been in that city; and while we were there we had the opportunity to visit the Martin Luther King Jr. Center for Non-Violent Social Change, which is located just up the street from the Ebenezer Baptist Church, "Daddy" King's church, in the neighborhood where young M.L. King spent his childhood. It was the only "touristy" thing we did while we were in Atlanta (we were much too busy being newlyweds to bother with such foolishness as art museums), but we made the most of it; we even bought each other T-shirts. And I spent an hour or so in the small museum there, which is filled with memorabilia of the Civil Rights Movement, and Dr. King's ministry. The one exhibit I found most fascinating was that of Dr. King's preaching robe, a robe not so different from the one I'm wearing now. It surprised me to discover that he was actually a rather short man; I had always envisioned him as some sort of giant, yet I doubt the man whom I imagined could have ever squeezed into the tiny robe I saw hanging there in that glass case. Nor would he have had to. For I realized in that moment, standing there in awe before that tiny robe, that stature is not always a function of physical size. Nor is the significance of a life extinguished by death, when all which that life stood for still burns within the hearts of others. And there is a vitality to all that Martin Luther King Jr. stood for, an immortality if you will, which still lives today beyond the grave. It is a vitality which grows from the capacity for self-sacrifice, from the willingness to stand faithfully in the presence of evil, and surrender one’s ego to the truth of a higher principle. It is an immortality born of our Strength to Love.
at the First Religious Society in Carlisle, Massachusetts
Sunday January 18th, 2004
I once saw an interview with the actor Ben Kingsley, who casually observed that the secret to his successful characterization of Mohandas Gandhi in the renown Richard Attenbourgh film of the same name, was his realization that Gandhi was not so much a saint who "stooped" to participate in politics as he was a politician struggling to become a saint. I've thought about that apparently offhand remark a great deal since first hearing it. Why is it that professional politicians are so universally held in such low esteem in our society, so much so that even honest-to-God “saintly” individuals (like, say, Jimmy Carter) inevitably appear "compromised" in the public eye when they attempt to participate in the political process? It reminds me of a story I once heard about the syndicated advice columnist Ann Landers, who was approached one evening by a member of the Senate at an Embassy Reception in Washington D.C.
"So you're Ann Landers," the Senator remarked. "Say something funny."
To which Ms Landers immediately responded "So you're a politician. Tell me a lie."
Political activity is the lifeblood of a free society; it is the means by which the will of the people becomes the law of the land. We lift up American Democracy as a model for all the world, yet for some reason we find it all too easy to believe that those who choose to practice politics as a vocation must be doing so from base motives, avariciously, deceitfully, with only their own advancement rather than the best interests of the country or even their own constituents at heart. It’s almost as though we believe that true saints must somehow be "above politics" -- unsullied by the strange bedfellows encountered in smoke-filled cloakrooms. Fools rush in where Angels fear to tread; and Saints, of course, are expected to behave like angels. Politicians on the other hand, remain free to behave like fools.
Of course, it’s not as if the politicians themselves don’t do plenty to bring on this sort of criticism. It’s almost enough to convert even a naive, wide-eyed optimistic Idealist like myself into a confirmed cynic. The events of this past week have been particularly egregious in this regard. While the Democrats were out west in Iowa engaging in their usual round-robin of mutual recrimination, insinuation, and name-calling known as a “Caucus,” the President flew to Atlanta to lay a wreath on the memorial of Martin Luther King Jr. (thus allowing him to bill the taxpayers for his travel), then rode across town to a $2000/plate fundraising dinner (where he raised more money in a single evening than the most credible African-American candidate, Carol Mosely Braun, raised during her entire campaign), after which he returned to Washington DC to announce a trillion-dollar program to send a man to Mars (most of which, if it is actually ever appropriated, will be spent in Texas and Florida: two states critical to the President’s re-election, and notorious for their efforts to circumvent the Voting Rights Act), and that incidentally, since Congress is now in recess, he is going to exercise his “emergency powers” under the Constitution to appoint Charles Pickering to the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, despite the fact that the controversial Judge had already failed twice to win Senate confirmation, and was opposed (because of his judicial record) by essentially every important Civil Rights organization in the country, including Dr. King’s own Southern Christian Leadership Conference. But Pickering is popular with the Religious Right because of his views on abortion, among other things, thus making his recess appointment a perfect opportunity for both parties to pander sanctimoniously to “the Faithful,” portraying themselves as the last bold defenders of all that is Good, and Moral, and True in our society, while characterizing their opponents as Evil Incarnate. Just to be fair, guess where Howard Dean is attending church this morning? That’s right, in Plains Georgia with Jimmy Carter. And don’t even get me started on all the self-righteous double-talk about civil unions, and the so-called “Healthy Marriage Initiative.”
But confronted with things like this, what are we then to think about that rare politician, like a Mohandas Gandhi, who truly does struggle to become a saint -- who seeks to express through his or her political convictions the high ethical and humanitarian principles of a profound religious faith? Actually, despite my own evolving cynicism, I suspect that this sort of politician is far more common than we generally assume, and that our appreciation of their efforts depends to a great extent upon the degree to which our own political opinions are in agreement with theirs. The road to sainthood is long and arduous, and the dividing line between “saint” and “fanatic” typically razor-thin; many are called but few are chosen; ultimately only history will decide whether or not the struggle was fruitful. Sainthood and the aspiration to sainthood are hardly one and the same. Indeed, so rarefied is our view of the former that often merely the ambition to attain it is enough to taint its purity in our eyes. Yet it would be equally misleading to assume that only those who do not seek it, who have their greatness thrust upon them, are somehow deserving of the mantle of our respect. The inner quality of sainthood is a peculiar combination of humility and arrogance: the arrogance to believe that one's deeply held principles and convictions are important enough to make a difference, and the humility to recognize that this challenge cannot be met by aspiration and strength of will alone.
Martin Luther King Jr. was only 26 years old when he was elected president of the Montgomery Improvement Association, an ad hoc black community group which had been organized to oversee the now famous Montgomery Bus Boycott. As best I can tell, judging from everything I have read, he probably didn't even want the job. At the time, King had been pastor of the Dexter Avenue Baptist Church for less than two years, and had only completed the final requirements for his Ph.D. at Boston University that previous spring. Furthermore, his selection as President of the M.I.A. was an overtly political choice. As a relative newcomer to the city of Montgomery, King had yet to become too strongly identified with any particular element within the black community, and thus it was felt that perhaps he could provide precisely the kind of neutral leadership which would allow all of the rival factions within that community to come together in this one common purpose. There was a downside consideration to his nomination as well. Should the boycott fail, as many of the more experienced black community leaders believed it might, this young preacher could easily be sacrificed without endangering these more established leaders' hard earned credibility with both the white establishment, and their own constituencies.
Knowing this aspect of the story, one might easily say that Martin Luther King Jr. did indeed have his greatness thrust upon him, and with the unanimous consent of older, wiser, and more politically savvy colleagues at that. But clearly, this would be only part of the tale. More importantly, there was an inner quality to this aspiring but untested religious leader, an intrinsic quality of saintliness if you will, which, once exposed, blossomed forth into a strength which enabled him to endure receiving dozens of threatening letters and telephone calls each day; to survive slander and harassment by police and other government authorities; to have the front of his parsonage blown off by dynamite while his wife and few-month-old child huddled in the kitchen...to experience all of the doubts and fears and pressures to which the human soul is vulnerable, and still not lose sight of the larger aspiration: a goal which in its very rightness and importance dwarfed both his abilities, and his frailties, as a human being.
To be sure, in many ways Martin Luther King Jr. did have his greatness thrust upon him: he happened to be in the right place, at the right time. But the reason we honor him with a national holiday on his birthday is because he also happened to be the right person to be there in Montgomery, Alabama in 1955, when Rosa Parks refused to give up her seat on a bus. Yes, there was an inner quality of greatness to him. But more importantly, he did not shy from his responsibilities when the need to express that greatness presented itself before him.
From Montgomery, as we all know, King went on to face new challenges and achieve new triumphs: in Birmingham and Selma, in Washington D.C. and Oslo, Norway, where he became the youngest man ever to receive a Nobel Peace prize. Yet I've often wondered whether or not King's greatest challenge and achievement might not have been related to the conflicts which he faced within his own soul, such as the temptation to "retire" as it were from the Civil Rights movement, and accept a lucrative post somewhere in academia, or to spend more time with his wife and his children, away from the death threats and the FBI wiretaps; to grow old in the bosom of the liberal white establishment, lecturing to wide-eyed freshmen about Socrates and Jesus, Gandhi and Thoreau, while writing bestselling books for Harper and Row.
These options were certainly made available to him many times. And yet he chose instead to continue to fill that role which destiny had thrust upon him there in Montgomery in 1955; and this, to me, seems a far more telling mark of King's true "saintly greatness" than any of his other achievements or laurels. It is not merely because King achieved great things that we celebrate his birth as a National holiday. It is also the price he was willing to pay in order to achieve these things -- not for his own personal benefit, but for the benefit of an entire society.
It is difficult for those of us who lack this inner quality of saintliness, this peculiar combination of humility and arrogance,to fully understand what was at stake in Martin Luther King Jr's decision to continue along the path that had been chosen for him, a path which eventually led him to his death on a motel balcony in Memphis. There have been those who have claimed that King was, in fact, a megalomaniac, or that he suffered from a "martyr complex," that his ego was such that he simply could not step out of the national limelight once he had tasted the sweetness of being Time magazine's "Man of the Year."
Nothing, I think, could be further from the truth.
King himself knew better than anyone what was at stake in the drama that was being played out in his frail, mortal human existence. And he spoke of it simply in terms of "The Strength to Love:" the power of God's own overflowing, passionate, creative love for human kind manifesting itself in a single human life. Perhaps it was a form of megalomania, a delusion of grandeur of the most grandiose proportions. But it was also an ultimate act of personal surrender, a martyrdom of the self in the truest sense of that word, as a witness to a creative power for justice far greater than one's own power or creativity.
In the final analysis we must recognize that it was not delusion, but vision, which animated King's career as a civil rights reformer. Commentator Gary Wills has noted that the changes which Martin Luther King Jr. brought to American society were "so large as to be almost invisible." In a few short years, King and those who worked with him swept away an entire system of American apartheid which had existed in the South for nearly a century. Men and women of my generation have had no experience of "whites only" lunch counters, restrooms, and drinking fountains; we have been educated in integrated schools, voted for and elected black politicians, patronized black-owned businesses; and, for the most part, we have done so without giving it second thought.
This is not to say that racial prejudice and discrimination no longer exist in this country. White Sheets and cross-burnings may seem like things of the past, but we still have hate crimes in this country; the Ku Klux Klan is still alive and kicking, and has spawned numerous imitators; access to jobs, housing, justice, health care, educational opportunity is still not completely color blind, nor anywhere near equally available to all. In many ways racism has become much more subtle, even sophisticated; it has replaced its white sheets with pinstriped suits, and is fueled as much by the ignorance and the naivete of the well-intentioned (who would just as soon not think about it, and who wish that the problem would simply "go away"), as it is by the malice of those few (albeit increasingly vocal) kooks who would just as soon trot segregation (or its functional equivalent) back out of the closet, if they thought they could get away with it.
Yet King's vision of a truly pluralistic, inclusive, and democratic society, in which individuals are judged by the quality of their characters and not the color of their skins, remains a vivid beacon of our future, untarnished in the nearly half-century which has now elapsed since the bus boycott in Montgomery, which first brought this man to our national attention.
It’s a little-known fact, but my ex-wife Margaret and I were married in Atlanta: at midnight on the Summer Solstice at the Peachtree Plaza hotel during the UUA General Assembly in 1985. It was the first time either of us had ever been in that city; and while we were there we had the opportunity to visit the Martin Luther King Jr. Center for Non-Violent Social Change, which is located just up the street from the Ebenezer Baptist Church, "Daddy" King's church, in the neighborhood where young M.L. King spent his childhood. It was the only "touristy" thing we did while we were in Atlanta (we were much too busy being newlyweds to bother with such foolishness as art museums), but we made the most of it; we even bought each other T-shirts. And I spent an hour or so in the small museum there, which is filled with memorabilia of the Civil Rights Movement, and Dr. King's ministry. The one exhibit I found most fascinating was that of Dr. King's preaching robe, a robe not so different from the one I'm wearing now. It surprised me to discover that he was actually a rather short man; I had always envisioned him as some sort of giant, yet I doubt the man whom I imagined could have ever squeezed into the tiny robe I saw hanging there in that glass case. Nor would he have had to. For I realized in that moment, standing there in awe before that tiny robe, that stature is not always a function of physical size. Nor is the significance of a life extinguished by death, when all which that life stood for still burns within the hearts of others. And there is a vitality to all that Martin Luther King Jr. stood for, an immortality if you will, which still lives today beyond the grave. It is a vitality which grows from the capacity for self-sacrifice, from the willingness to stand faithfully in the presence of evil, and surrender one’s ego to the truth of a higher principle. It is an immortality born of our Strength to Love.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
